There is a whole category of TV shows that crave the patina of roughhewn, gutsy, authentic "art" with rawness, vulgarity, and a plethora of "fucks" and "motherfucker" and poop references. He hero is usually a male in his mid twenties who is addicted to alcohol or drugs and has pissed off all the remarkably charming women in his life with his unreliability and infidelities and suddenly is confronted with an opportunity to redeem himself by helping a young woman achieve a pointless objective, usually to do with family, which she irrationally craves to achieve no matter how forbidding the obstacles are because she will hector the poor schmuck into taking on the brave tasks to achieve it and after numerous repetitive misadventures and failures will finally end up with everyone together in a lovely cottage on the sea having wine and extolling each other's loveliness and virtue. As I have said many times, there is nothing more boring in film or literature than a fucking drunk. I have grown to despise this character, this trope, this avatar of the viewer's engagement with authentic life. Here's the sketch: Lucky Flynn, the drunken loser, the boring, annoying, self-serving, dip, has fled his family after impregnating his brothers wife with Billie who does not yet know that he is her dad (it's always a girl, isn't it?). He meets up with Meg Adams who is out joy-riding in her brother's truck. They have to bring Flynn's piano back to his dying mom's house. Toby Flynn is still enraged about the infidelity with Suzie. Mom is dying in that cinematically lovely way of movie mom-deaths, forgiving and healing and all that that. The rest of the series consists of Meg and Lucky screaming at each other until we get the really nauseating part in the last few episodes, where we learn that Meg's heart was broken because Lucky didn't call her for four years, and we learn that Lucky has a broken heart because there must be a wonderful excuse for his fucking despicable character and behavior so we can enjoy the virtual embrace at the end, the mawkish acceptance of his daughter for his absence from her life and the deceit, and, unbelievably, be awestruck by his abrasive song about it all performed by him and his daughter for a stunningly compliant audience who don't even mind the contemptible cliche of Billie not wanting to perform because she's just so goddamned modest and humble and all that, and fuck, if you really really really insist, all right, I'll sing the song and blow you all away in the way of all rigged movie audiences. This is a movie filled to brim with bullshit about humans, and human character, and emotions, and how people behave when they are confronted with their selfish contemptible selves. It will be adored. And there it is: rating of 8.0 on IMDB.
Tim Minchin, Milly Alcock, Heather Mitchell, Daniel Lapaine, Ella Scott Lynch, Daniel Frederiksen
Clever, well-paced documentary on Theranos founder and CEO Elizabeth Holmes and how she leveraged a shaky conception of an electronic diagnostic device into a multi-billion dollar fraud that collapsed into nothing after the Wall Street Journal published findings about how tests and results were faked or covertly farmed out to real separate devices. Holmes is fascinating: does she really believe what she is saying (she seems to). And why were so many rich, older men captivated by her (including George Shultz and, at first, his son Tyler). Does a nice job exploring the mentality of silicon valley (fake it until you make) epitomized by Microsoft's disgraceful introduction of its graphical user interface long before a viable OS actually existed (though it's not mentioned here). The shocking willingness of establishment politicians and financiers to believe Holmes's BS raises questions in your mind about what else these people believe that isn't true. George Shultz, for god's sake, was a powerful government official. Who else fooled him? Gibney gives good, clear explanations of what Theranos claimed to be doing, how it (didn't) work, and the weirdness of Holmes.
Alex Gibney, Elizabeth Holmes, George Shultz, Dan Ariely, Roger Parloff, Erika Cheung, Phyllis Gardner, Tyler Shultz, Ken Suletta, Ramesh Balwani, Errol Morris, John Carreyrou, David Boies
19-year-old Elizabeth Holmes was the founder and CEO of Theranos, in 2003, a company that claimed to have invented a small device that could instantly analyze a drop of blood and provide critical information about the health of the subject. Holmes succeeded-- through charm?-- in recruiting a remarkable roster of luminaries to the board of Theranos including George Schultz, Henry Kissinger, James N. Mattis, William Perry, Betsy DeVos and Sam Nunn. She gave Joe Biden (then VP) a tour of the factory. Nobody appears to have tested the device systematically and some of the earliest purchasers cancelled their contracts when they realized Holmes couldn't demonstrate an actual working model. Holmes was eventually charged with fraud and sentenced to 11 years in prison. Nathan Fielder was invited into her home, which she shared with Billy Evans, to do a documentary on her. From there it is difficult to sort out who is conning whom. Holmes states that she believes she did nothing wrong and the device works. Fielder questions her but not in a systematic or journalistically responsible manner. Fielder always falls back on cringe, though less so here than in his earlier programs. And there is no attempt really to explain why so many people invested so much money in Theranos, or why those luminaries joined the board. There is supposed to be a shocking twist, which I finally figured out was the fact that Billy Evans had negotiated a payout from the movie's profits, without Holmes in the room. Did she know or did she not? That's one of the things the viewer is invited to deconstruct. Fielder than brings in Amanda Seyfried (who played Holmes in an earlier biopic) and creates re-enactments of the scenes he is unable to film after she enters prison. Fascinating without being deeply impressive. Holmes in interesting as an artifact of a brutal era of tech monsters exploiting massive numbers of users for profit.
Elizabeth Holmes, Nathan Fielder, Christopher Abbot, Amanda Seyfried, Elizabeth Holmes, Lance Oppenheim, Billy Evans
Fascinating documentary about a mediocre popular poet, Mary Oliver. Waters tries to imbue Mary Oliver with esteem from Stephen Colbert, John Waters, Oprah Winfrey, Maria Schriver, and others, but can't hide the banal character of her work every time it is quoted. She cites a review by James Dickey that dissed her and then quotes the New York Times, triumphantly, 30 years later, that Oliver is the most popular poet in America. Well, yes. And loved by Oprah. Yet the documentary itself is lovely featuring loads of beautiful old 8mm footage of unknown provenance (I can't find anything about the sources online). Some of it is of Mary Oliver and her partner, Molly Malone Cook, who also managed her literary affairs. Oliver scored a gig helping Edna St. Vincent-Millay's sister manage her estate after the poet's death. From there, she studied at several colleges without getting a degree and eventually became a teacher of creative writing for years at Sweet Briar College and then Bennington College. Yes, there is such a place as "Sweet Briar College", though it almost closed in 2015. She lived in rustic simplicity in Provincetown and was known for her walks among nature and her reflections on her walks among nature and various critters she came upon. There is a brief allusion to a late affair with a younger woman (after Molly died) which was disastrous-- without telling us why.
Mary Oliver, John Waters, Stephen Colbert, Maria Shriver, Oprah Winfrey, Molly Malone Cook
Vastly over-rated, ponderous, suffocating, leaden version of the operatic Steinbeck novel (which is also seriously over-rated). Follows the tragic lives of the Trasks, two brothers, one dynamic and bitter, and the other passive and brittle, as they struggle with their father's legacy and their own faulted characters. Adam foolishly marries Cathy Ames, prostitute who crawls up to house one night, beaten and bloody, while Charles looks after the farm and remains home. Cathy gets pregnant by Charles but abandons Adam and the children (Cal and Aron) to become a madame at a whore-house in Salinas. Cal eventually discovers the dark secret (he and Aron had been told that Cathy was dead) and the scandal destroys Aron. The problem is that the original novel is soap opera and the miniseries is worse. Scenes are static and dull. Nobody has any life outside of the lines they recite to each other in discrete chunks of antiseptic platitude. Lee, a servant, acts like a colleague, which is enlightened but anti-historical. Cathy takes a long, long time to assassinate Faye and it's not exciting to watch. Then we are supposed to believe that Ethel, who found the remains of the vials of poison she used, would be a genuine threat to her, as if the authorities of the time would have found these artifacts convincing and complete. Then she seems to lose all of the hardness and fortitude you would think a whorehouse madam would possess in 1900's Salinas and breaks down when she realizes her sons know her scandalous reputation. The women are not treated kindly-- actually, not treated at all. Even Abra is a bland composite of feminine attachment, also capable of iniquity. Deaths come along and fade away quickly. Lustfully filmed but a crashing bore that I couldn't wait for it to end.
Florence Pugh, Christopher Abbott, Mike Faist, Hoon Lee, Joseph Zada, Joe Anders, Robert Morgan, Zoe Phillips, Brad McMurray
Frances Haugen, about the time of the 2020 election, worked at Facebook in the "Civic Integrity" team. She was initially impressed with the genuine commitment to integrity and positive social influence she found there but soon discovered that Facebook's leadership had realized the it was losing the attention of the most desirable users to TikTok and other platforms. The Civic Integrity team was disbanded Facebook began to enact algorithms that steered users to controversial and deceitful posts. Facebook knew that people reacted more strongly-- and often shared-- posts that were misleading, deceitful, or inflammatory. It also decided not to tag political ads when they were contrary to factual knowledge. Haugen was distressed by this turn in Facebook's culture and when a reporter at the Wall Street Journal, Jeff Horwitz, reached out to the members of the team for inside information, she willingly came forward. In real life, she was far more outgoing and assertive than the movie makes her out to be, but the gist of it is there. Her disclosures led to government hearings and lawsuits. But, did it influence Facebook? Not yet. Well-acted and directed, and well-written (of course). Sorkin does a great job of laying out complex ideas and situations and building momentum for the big moment-- which might leave you feeling that a serious issue has been solved. Has it? Facebook (now Meta) pays out close to a billion dollars to settle lawsuits, but probably considers the money to be an operating expense. Jeremy Strong is very good as Zuckerberg, conveying his rather icy, mercenary attitude towards social harm, and the children whose self-image is harmed by Instagram. He reluctantly finally takes down Trump's posts during the January 6 insurrection. But he is known to have asserted that Facebook is "beyond government". Note that the Charlie character, played by Bill Burr, is entirely fictional.
Jeremy Allen White, Betty Gilpin, Gbenga Akinnagbe, Nelson Franklin, Kelley Pereira, Mikey Madison, Jeremy Strong, Bill Burr, Wunmi Mosaku,
This is allegedly a comedy, and it was nominated for numerous Emmys in that category. What is it really? A mismatched collection of horrorific and comedic sequences with no inner coherence or logic, and no real suspense. The horror scenes are not horrifying and the comedy is sparse. Mayor Tom Loftis is trying to promote Widow's Bay as the new cool destination for tourism and he is convinced that local myths about hauntings and ghosts will hurt the cause. And this is the first sign of the incoherence to come: tourist won't be attracted to a quaint island village that claims to be haunted? His friend Wyck keeps whacking him about the horrors to come and it's never clear if or why Loftis should believe him. He is annoying in any case. There are other colorful locals like Rosemary and Ruth and Patricia to provide comedy, I suppose, and Loftis's son, Evan, who provides some cringeworthy sentiment (we are supposed to moved, I guess, by Loftis' concern for his safety). The haunted creatures seem to vary-- there's no clear character to them. Are they witches or ghosts or animals or specters or what? I don't know. And the internal logic about what causes them to emerge and attack people is confused, and it's unclear who they have attacked or why. At one point is manifests as some kind of horrific storm and Loftis has everyone rounded up and locked into a shelter, which gets weird. Nobody questions the whole process? Or defiantly stay in their home? There is a secret passage that Evan uses to escape the shelter-- really? It's all a big mess and pretty boring.
Matthew Rhys, Kate O'Flynn, Kevin Carroll, Dale Dickey, Kingston Rumi Southwick, Stephen Root, Lauren Bittner, K Callan
Beautiful, subtle film about corrupt Hollywood in the 1930's, during the depression. Faye is a young, blond actress with aspirations. Tod is a graphic artist with ambitions who makes the connection and gets real work. He becomes an observer of the tragic unfolding and plans a masterpiece, the burning of LA, a vision realized in the end. Harry (Faye's father) is a washed up vaudevillian and actor, a clown reduced to selling "solvent" door to door. Homer is a naive, sincere, ridiculously pious man with means living in a nearby apartment, who wishes only to make Faye happy (while accepting that she will never love him or marry him). There is Abe Kusich, a dwarf, and a cowboy who carries a torch for Faye. Tod loves Faye but she only has eyes for the remote possibility of Hollywood success. There are long diversionary sequences (something about rooster fights, an evangelistic service that is mesmerizing and suggests Aimee Semple McPherson, Harry going door to door). There is a weird child, Adore Loomis, who provokes and mocks Homer until he cracks up. And a colossal mess of an ending which I don't think worked. One of the reasons it didn't work for me was the bombastic score to drive home the chaos and violence of the riot at the theatre. Except, perhaps, as the intended message: that Hollywood turns audiences into a violent mob of zombies who would just as soon tear someone apart as worship them. This is an embryonic "Mulholland Drive", and like "Mulholland Drive" it possesses marked flaws.
Donald Sutherland, William Atherton, Karen Black, Burgess Meredith, Geraldine Page, Richard Dysart, Bo Hopkins, Lelia Goldoni, Jackie Haley, Billy Barty
Another one of those "based on true events" except for most facts movies. Which is a why do you bother with any facts at all if you are going to fill the story with shit like this? Rose Gooding was not remotely Irish. She did not live in a common law relationship with a black person: she was married to William Gooding and had two children by him along with a daughter from a previous relationship. They shared a house with Rose's sister, Ruth Russell. Policewoman Gladys Moss was at least a woman but she was not black or Asian, and I have no doubt that the judge wasn't black either. A group of misfit women in Littlehampton did not plot, like the Hardy Boys, to apprehend Edith by following her and trapping her with invisible ink on the stamp: the Post Office did that. Why oh why take a truly remarkable and compelling story and turn it into this banal cartoon? And waste talents like Jessie Buckley and Olivia Coleman on this drivel? The basic story is about a woman in the 1920's complaining to the police about obscene-- I mean, really obscene-- letters that were sent to her, and accusing her neighbor, Rose Gooding, of sending them. This woman, Edith Swan, had previously accused Rose of abusing a child but protective services found no evidence to support the accusation. The letters went on and on, to many other people, and eventually Rose was convicted based largely on her dubious "character". She used colorful language and had a personality. She was convicted twice and served time even while some investigators noticed that the handwriting on the letters did not match hers, and at least one investigator noted that it was similar to Edith's but kind of refused to process this fact to logical conclusion. The scandal became a national story in England and eventually involved high levels of police and justice officials. Eventually, suspicion focused entirely on Edith and her father and Rose was exonerated and compensated. Edith was imprisoned. There is a lot of rich implication about society and class and judgement in this story, but "Wicked Little Letters" is more interested in progressive politics (having a woman of color play the policewoman and giving her more credit than she deserves for solving the case, and having three women misfits lead the effort to trap Edith into incriminating herself) than in insight or real drama. The police, Edith's family, and most other characters are cartoons. But the worst thing about the movie is the way it shifts scales of justice so that even Edith becomes, fundamentally, a victim of male oppression, rather than an envious, jealous, cruel manipulator and liar. Having Rose and Edith share a conspiratorial laugh at the end was worse than offensive. It was vulgar and stupid. Somehow Edith's father, a ridiculously pious Christian, and the police men who insulted Officer Gladys Moss, are the real villains. But they did not cause an innocent woman to be locked up for a year in a brutal prison, separated from her children, and savaged in public perception. That is unforgivable. Best scene in the movie: Jessie Buckley flashing her buttocks as she flees the police. Not in the script: she decided to do it on her own.
Jessie Buckley, Olivia Colman, Timothy Spall, Gemma Jones, Malachi Kirby, Alisha Weir, Anjan Vasan, Hugh Skinner, Lolly Adefope, Eileen Atkins, Joanna Scanlan
Seen on flight from Paris to Toronto. Sometimes funky, often mysterious story about an 11-year-old girl, Fuki, trying to make sense of her world, with her father dying of a terminal illness and an unstable mother who might be seeking romance, neither of whom have much time to pay attention to Fuki. Fuki is a classic pre-adolescent: the world is all new so why should death or infidelity shock her? She tells her classmates a story about herself in which she is murdered. Fuki intercepts some of her mother's potential online romances and actually goes to meet one of these men, in the scariest sequence of the film. What are we going to see? The film is so off-kilter that we don't know for sure. Fuki becomes interested in hypnotism and tries it out on a neighbor who reveals shocking personal events. Her father seeks quack remedies for his terminal illness. All the adults around her are dysfunctional and unbalanced. A weakness in the film is that we don't know where a balance might be, where the gravity is.
Yui Suzuki, Hikari Ishida, Lily Franky, Ayumu Nakajima, Yumi Kawai, Jeffrey Rowe
Appallingly bad-- I mean, really awful-- story about three secretaries who take revenge on their rude boss, Franklin Hart. Judy, Violet, and Doralee aren't particularly feminist. They are more offended by Hart's meanness than the injustice of the system they are part of, though, at the end, they tag themselves as activists for day care, equal wages, and flexible hours-- none of which are tied specifically to the sexism of Hart. There is a huge problem with tone here: it's mostly slapstick but then there is a gun. Hart demeans Violet by demanding she bring him coffee but in the end they get day care for the employees. Problems seem to arise at random and are solved at random. Were they making this up as they went along? The acting is uniformly horrible, with the odd moment from Lily Tomlin rising above the miasma. Even the theme song is really banal. You can tell that somebody in the production thought particular sequences would be hilarious but even when they are a little funny they are abbreviated, curtailed, fumbled.
Dolly Parton, Jane Fonda, Lily Tomlin, Dabney Coleman, Sterling Hayden, Elizabeth Wilson, Henry Jones, Marian Mercer, Earl Boen
When will I learn? A number of reviewers gave this film high praise while averring that it was historically accurate (not just "inspired by") and more authentic than most. No, it is not. It is poorly written, poorly acted, and poorly directed. It is predictable and contrived. And they made shit up to make it more dramatic, the most egregious example of which was the birth of James Stagg's baby (not even close to D-Day and there was no bombing of the hospital, hence no offer from Kay Summersby to go to the hospital to see that she was safe). And where is Sverre Petterssen, the Norwegian meteorologist who actually had more influence on Eisenhower's decision? And, of course, very little reference to anybody but Americans landing: Omaha and Utah beaches are cited but not Juno or Sword. Everybody's holding their breath for the American advances (which were late) while never acknowledging the relative success of the Canadians and the British. Sheesh. The screaming matches never happened. Stagg (ineptly played by Andrew Scott-- a role he was not suited for) is rather annoying little man who doesn't subscribe to Irving Krick's idea of "analog" forecasting: taking previous weather situations to predict subsequent conditions. They argue in front of Eisenhower who inexplicably tells them, yes, disagree, that will help me decide. (I would have believed him hearing from all three, but not the way they show it in "Pressure"). We don't get any explanation at all of why Eisenhower would suddenly trust Stagg over Krick, but, predictably, Stagg eventually solicits Krick's support so all is well in the end. (Note that American war historians regularly credit Krick with the forecast that Eisenhower relied on when he gave the go command.) We get a windy storm to come along at the right time to prove that Stagg is right. Eisenhower talks to Stagg in a way no superior-- especially in the military-- would talk to a lower-ranked officer. We get-- ridiculously-- Stagg yelling at the assembly of generals that they'll ruin everything if they don't listen to him. By then we've lost the essential character of this relationship: it is not up to Stagg to make the decision. He is there to give information to the staff and if they don't like his information, they can quickly dispense with him. All of it is melodrama designed to make a more thrilling movie but it isn't thrilling at all. It's tiresome and boring, and the subplot of the pregnancy is offensive. Sophomoric.
Andrew Scott, Brendan Fraser, Kerry Condon, Chris Messina, Damian Lewis, Tamain Topolski
A far more comprehensive and caustic version of Serpico: Danny Ciello is a narcotics detective engaged in routine, numerous acts of corruption, along with his fellow team members. The corruption is embedded in the job, laughed about, justified, and rationalized. They have been conducting their malfeasance with impunity for so long they barely bother to conceal it. Ciello has a crisis of conscience and when asked to help with an investigation by Internal Affairs and federal government officials, he agrees as long as he is never forced to implicate his former partners. Of course, this proves difficult. He and his family go into hiding and he seeing the inevitable he tries to persuade his former partners to "come in" and confess. In this intelligent take on a true story, there are no heroes and no pure villains. The corrupt detectives point out that in many cases, when they steal money from drug dealers, they are issuing the only punishment they actually face (after their lawyers get involved). The feel entitled to their share of the booty. The debate among prosecutors and investigators when they discover that Danny has been lying is intense, even-handed, and unresolvable. Some of his former colleagues committed suicide as they faced indictment. Frank Serpico knew the real Danny, Robert Leuci, and recommended him to the Knapp Commission unaware of the dept of corruption he was involved with. While I empathize with the prosecutors who wanted to indict Leuci, it appears, from the film, that he was promised that his testimony would not be used against his former colleagues, and then it was. Well-filmed, brilliantly acted by everyone except-- ironically-- Treat Williams, the star. Williams gambled with a sometimes flamboyant, overly emotional portrayal, shrieking and shrill, and pathetic at times. I think he misjudged it. Pacino had been considered by correctly judged the role to be too similar to "Serpico". The sequence in which prosecutors and investigators argue about whether indict Danny was richly compelling and maybe one of the most intelligent treatment of justice issues in any film of that era.
Treat Williams, Jerry Orbach, Richard Foronjy, Don Billett, Kenny Marino, Carmine Caridi, Bob Balaban, Norman Parker, James Tolkan, Steve Inwood, Lindsay Crouse, Robert Christian, Michael Beckett
Oscar Restropo was once a successful young poet who published two books and won a national prize. But since the birth of his daughter, Daniela, he's been nothing more than an impotent drunk, living with his mother, avoiding work, and pissing off everyone he knows with arguments and drunken reveries. Forced to take a teaching job so he can offer help to Daniela for university (which she doesn't want), he encounters Yurlady, a young woman with a gift for poetry: simple, intuitive, unpretentious. He begins to promote her to a poets association, to get her awards and recognition, and encourage her to expand her repertoire. Efrain, another poet, however, sees Yurlady as grant-bait, in particular from a Dutch diplomat who is entranced by her youth and charming talents. A poetry reading becomes a disaster when Yurlady, along with some other young poets, gets drunk and passes out, and Oscar stupidly decides to just drive her home and drop her at the bottom of the stairs of their apartment where she lives with numerous extended relatives. Suspicions are raised, Oscar is accused, Daniela is repelled, the school wants to fire him. The viewer-- and Oscar-- are never offered and easy out here. The story is sometimes emotionally brutal, unkind, and defiantly harsh. Perhaps Yurlady is not credibly tardy in exonerating Oscar. No easy redemption at the end, though there is some redemption. Exceptionally well acted and written, cinematically dull, often abrasive, but daring and original, and who gives poetry this kind of attention anymore?
Ubeimar Rios, Rebeca Andrade, Guillermo Cardona, Margarita Soto, Hugo Valencia, Humberto Restrepo, Evelin Montoya Sanchez, Alisson Correa
Another film written by the director. And another mind-numbing sequel in what had been a fairly interesting series. The plot is incredibly banal. Jason Bourne is lost in Athens, fighting for a living, mourning, I presume, his lost love. Nick Parsons, plotting against the CIA now, has uncovered some pertinent information about nefarious CIA plots and informs Bourne. Well, we need something to make it seem to matter: how about Jason's father was in on the original scheme but backed out when it looked like his son might be become an assassin. Bourne sets out to foil the new plot, which includes more assassinations and using a social media company to conduct mass surveillance. A very lovely young operative in the CIA supports him, even if she might not be as loyal to him as she looks-- but, hey, it's Alicia Vikander, so nobody has to mind. Of course we end up with a very derivative movie, Greengrass copyin his own work on "The Bourne Ultimatum" (but written by Tony Gilroy). In particular, a long-- very long-- car chase at the end is like a wet, sloppy, copy of the one from "Ultimatum" and incredibly poorly film. The physics of it are preposterous, the cuts and jerky camera are obviously intended to cover blandly cartoonish collisions and illogical jumps. It was worse than boring: it was aggressively mind-numbing. Then we get the utterly predictable confrontation with Dewey with the attractive girl entering at the right moment, and the familiar sequence of Bourne creeping up on her and surprising her at the end before pulling of a Shane exit. 170 cars and all coherence and credibility were destroyed in the chase scene. Keep in mind that Matt Damon refused to provide the voice for a video game version of the franchise because he felt the game was "too violent".
Matt Damon, Tommy Lee Jones, Alicia Vikander, Vincent Cassel, Julia Stiles, Riz Ahmed, Ato Essandoh, Scott Shepherd, Vinzenz Kiefer
Semi-autobiographical film about a Hungarian family that moves to Vancouver while struggling to deal with the eldest son's mental and emotional issues. Jeremy acts strangely, doesn't listen, climbs onto the roof, steals and shoplifts, and seems to pose a danger to his much younger siblings. We see things through the eyes of Sasha, who comes back to us an adult trying to understand what happened, and why Jeremy was impossible to manage and had to be put out to foster care at one point (apparently more than once). Elliptical and understated, though not well-acted, "Blue Hero" is a compelling narrative of melancholy: there is no magic to be had, no dramatic cures, no hidden trauma to be found and excised. Jeremy is just trouble and inexplicable and frustrating to his family and his therapists. "Blue Heron" deserves a lot of credit for avoiding the obvious trajectories in order to give us an honest, authentic account of a familial despair any of us can know from families we know. I have some "twins" but really there is almost no film like this.
Eylul Guven, Edik Beddoes, Iringo Reti, Adam Tompa, Liam Serg, Preston Drabble, Amy Zimmer
This is a piece of shit. It is a cardinal belief of mine that addiction is almost always fucking boring. And my lack of synchronicity with the general movie-going public and critics is reflected in the fact that I find many films that feature a main character's self-destructive abuse of drugs or alcohol boring while many critics find them-- contrary to all the evidence-- "deep". In what perverse way is it deep to watch someone stupidly damage and destroy his own intellectual faculties? It is almost always implied that the person drinks or does drugs because he or she has somehow apprehended a monumentally significant truth about reality. And those films never show us that truth because they don't really know what it is, and if they did, they wouldn't know how to show it. Gabriel Byrne, playing his real age, is Samuel O'Shea, a twice-divorced college professor, who has a brain tumor (oh PLEASE spare us), and has hallucinations of his late father and former lovers and other flotsams of memory, which, we are supposed to believe, leads him to deep contemplation of life, love, and mortality, and inspire him to embark on the great novel he always thought he would write. Even the lesser Cohen songs on the soundtrack-- "Hallelujah" being the only A lister, Bird on the Wire, I'll Make You Sorry, Memories, Un Canadien Errant, Why Don't you Try, and Heart With no Companion, can't rescue this drivel. A lame subplot has Samuel trying to save his alienated daughter from addiction-- why? A stunningly banal attempt at a redemption theme? It dies quickly. Poorly acted, poorly filmed, badly edited. And another monument to my conviction that most great musical artists (with the exception of the Beatles) should never make films (are you listening Neil Young, Nick Cave, Bob Dylan?). Okay, Leonard didn't make this film, but Bissonnette is a Cohenista deluxe (he has built other films around Cohen's music) and suffers from the same delusions. Maybe he should have watched "McCabe and Mrs. Miller" for tips.
Gabriel Byrne, Jessica Pare, Brian Gleeson, Antoine Olivier Pilon, Karellle Tremblay, Pascale Bussieres
True story, aside from the facts. Droopy, bland, and homogenized biopic that leaves out pretty well everything interesting-- if there is anything interesting about Michael Jackson, other than his popular success-- and is so skeptical of it's own conceit that it insists on telling the viewer, in dialogue, at every opportunity, how fabulous and successful Michael Jackson was. I didn't think any biopic could make a dull celebrity even more dull, but this one did. We don't even get the trashy pleasure of Elizabeth Taylor or Diana Ross or Oprah Winfrey, as the makers decided to avoid any potential legal problems and copyright issues by simply ignoring big chunks of Jackson's biography-- especially, of course, the child-abuse allegations. And no, Jackson did not choreograph the thriller video: Michael Peters did. And Jackson did not "write" most or probably any of his hit songs: various other writers did, though he probably piggy-backed his credit on the arrangements as many producers like Barry Gordy do. This Michael doesn't grab his crotch, even while performing the antiseptic "Bad". The singing is a blend of Jaafar Jackson's lame vocals and the actual recordings. None of the other personages in this film actually exist apart from being a prop. Yes, he did burn his hair in the Pepsi commercial, which, we are led to believe, may have tripped Jackson's future addictions. No surprise to me that I didn't care at all for Jackson, but surprised that it did such a poor job of praising him. Fuqua is clueless about how to show an artist at work, at the delicious interplay between musicians, arrangers, composers, and engineers in the studio, about rehearsals, about agents and contracts and production deals. He didn't even know how to milk the actual dynamics of sudden popularity, being played on the radio and tv, and the impact of fame. There is not a single good acting performance in the film partly because the makers didn't care and weren't interested in anybody except Michael. Dolman Domingo as Joseph is intense but that is not the same as compelling; Jaafar Jackson (Michael's nephew) floats through narrative like a blissed out moonie. He is simply terrible, except at dancing, which doesn't make up for anything.
Jaafar Jackson, Nia Long, Juliano Valdi, Colman Domingo, Jayden Harville, Liv Symone, Laura Harrier, Larenz Tate
I have frequently observed that many film-makers today believe, like James Cameron, either that they can write as well as a professional writer or that viewers don't care. Whatever the case, Nolan is the writer for a film he may or may not have directed well and it shows: the story is reduced from a striking myth into a banal succession of brutal miseries inflicted upon Odysseus and his men until Odysseus (the men are all dead) has learned his lesson. What is the lesson? It appears to be the shocking revelation that war is bad. We learn this lesson by watching Odysseus and his men participate in innumerable glorious slaughters. Odysseus' wisdom is incredibly cheap, coming as it does only after he has revenged himself upon the cartoonishly despicable suitors. Nolan has inflicted upon the story more than a few modern-- thus anachronistic-- sentimentalities, especially in the egregiously overwrought and contrived reunion with Penelope who is lavishly tearful. Nolan indulges ruthlessly two of the features of recent "artistic" films that I like the least: method acting and hand-held jerky camera motion especially during battle sequences. I can't tell if the scenes are well-staged or not-- well, they are not. We just see a montage of tremulous camera angles and fast cuts and sometimes water all orchestrated to relentless thumping bass effects. Matt Damon really doesn't have the heft for the role, and Tom Holland seems a bit effeminate for his. Elliot Page as Sinon is just peculiar, but gives it some character. Anne Hathaway is either overwrought or underwrought depending on the moment. Hugely disappointing but I am glad that a film-maker finally addressed the question every adolescent boy has about the Trojan Horse: where did they go to the bathroom when they were inside the horse? The answer: inside the horse.
Matt Damon, Robert Pattinson, Corey Hawkins, Jarreth J. Merz, Tom Holland, Elliot Page, Anne Hathaway
Given the talent available to director Donaldson it is almost shocking how dull the drama in "The Bounty" is. Historically accurate-- generally-- account of the famous Bounty Mutiny of 1789-04-28 in which Christian Fletcher, after months of disaffection with Lieutenant Bligh, took command of the Bounty and put Bligh along with about 17 other loyal seaman out to sea in a skiff. Remarkably, Bligh sailed through hazardous islands, hostile natives, and enormous navigational impediments to reach Kupang, a Dutch colony. Meanwhile, Fletcher Christian dropped many of the mutineers off at Tahiti where they chose to stay in spite of the threat of arrest, and sailed to Pitcairn's island where they burned the Bounty and established a colony with some women and men from Tahiti that they had taken with. Great raw material, but many scenes are flat, banal, or schematic (the storm lashing the ship, the men carousing with the Tahitian women, the Admiralty ruling on Bligh's Court Martial). Everyone seems to be waiting to read their lines or carouse or look angry. The flogging scenes look like a sophomoric rendering of a flogging: lots of anguished looks and loud whip noises and groans. Then it seems like they ran out of time, wrapping up parts of the story that were potentially more interesting than the storm or the carousing. Read about what happened on Pitcairn's Island: a great chunk of fascinating drama is left on the shelf. Music by Vangelis is more interesting, at least, than any John Williams score. The reconstruction of the ship is wonderful, and the attention to details of the life on these ships is appreciated. The characters of the Tahitian women are facile and cosmetic: they exist to provide the men with an object and seem to have no existence beyond their lovely semi-naked bodies. Why is Christian so enchanted with Mauatua, other than the obvious?
Anthony Hopkins, Mel Gibson, Laurence Olivier, Edward Fox, Daniel Day-Lewis, Bernard Hill, Liam Neeson, Wi Kuki Kaa, Tevaite Vernette, Philip Martin Brown, Malcolm Terris, Neil Morrissey
Amazingly kinetic film about two couples who are struggling with fidelity, jealousy, and responsibility. Odd film that sort of affirms fidelity and then kind of doesn't. Ashley and Carey are driving to visit Julie and Paul when Ashley drops a bombshell: she wants out of their 1 year old marriage. Meanwhile, Julie and Paul brag to to their friends about their "open" marriage. Carey decides to test Paul's broad-mindedness only to find that Paul is not really very accepting when it comes to his best friend and his wife and a hilarious, long drawn-out fight ensues. Ashley finds an assortment of new lovers. Carey is on again off again with Julie. Paul is imprisoned for fraud. Everyone is confused and confusing. It's all very funny at times and spirited but I doubt many viewers will find that these characters resemble anyone they know very much. Fresh and witty if not quite as resonant with real human character as, say, a Woody Allen film. Clearly, however, this film owes a lot of "Midsummer Night's Dream" and the Woody Allen and Bergman films that echo it.
Dakota Johnson, Adria Arjona, Kyle Marvin, Michael Angelo Covino, Simon Webster, Charlie Gillespie, Tyrone Benskin, David Castaneda
Confounding film from the esteemed Mike Leigh, about a woman, Pansy, who is incredibly critical and dismissive of everything. I mean, to an extreme: most of the film consists of Pansy absolutely raving about how bad things are, how badly people are behaving, how ill-treated she is, to the stoic consternation of her wastrel son Moses and patient husband Curtley and sister Chantelle. One seriously question Leigh's judgement here: do you really want to spend the majority of a 90 minute film displaying this utterly savage woman who obviously hates herself and everyone around her and assumes they all hate her, no matter what assurances they give her that they do not. It's a strange film because, like most of Leigh's films, the acting is superb, and the script never condescends to the audience, and the secondary characters have some richness even if they are mostly very passive. You are going to think about Pansy's attitude and why she is that way if she isn't right, in some ways. But you also can't wait for another character to breath some life into the story (which they do, a few times). Pansy's husband is not a martyr and her son really is indolent and selfish. Her nieces offer a model of generous, kind humanity, in contrast to Pansy, and it's a relief to see them.
Marianne Jean-Baptiste, Michele Austin, David Webber, Tuwaine Barrett, Ani Nelson, Sophia Brown, Jonathan Livingstone, Llewella Gideon
Elliptical, obtuse documentary about a Chinese family from Taiwan with a history, and the connection and disconnectedness of a younger generation born and raised in New Jersey. Vicky Du is the filmmaker, narrator, and daughter of the film. She wants to understand her family better through interviews with her brother, parents, uncles and aunts and cousins, and others. Interestingly, her grandparents and their families suffered horrendous abuse at the hands of the Communists in mainland China, while she and her brother find issue with their emotional health in New Jersey.
Vicky Du, Andrew Du
Takashi Watanabe is an old widower, and an esteemed former college professor and writer and translator. One night, he arranges for a young sex worker, Akiko, to come to his apartment. But what he's interested in is a dinner together and conversation. Akiko is not amused at first: she undresses and crawls into his bed asks him if he isn't sleepy. The next day, he drives her to a class at a university where he sees her boyfriend berating her. He has a conversation with the boyfriend and things grow tense from there. Not where you expect. The chaste relationship strikes me as disingenuous: he acts a little as if he didn't know what she would have expected. Then, the rapport they develop isn't very developed at all. When she calls him for help, one wonders if she doesn't have any other friends, though, with a bit of stretch, one could understand that she would call him. It's all very slow-moving and deliberative and not as satisfying some of Kiarostami's better work like "Through the Olive Trees" or "And Life Goes On" and "Close-up". I had feeling that Kiarostami's co-director Banafsheh Modaressi or co-writer Mohammad Rahmani steered the narrative away from Kiarostami's usual flavor. A lot of scenes feature glass and reflection, as if Watanabe is being confused by the outward glare of Akiko's charm and innocence. The ending is abrupt and unsatisfying. It is a pity Reiko Mori wasn't given more time as Akiko's friend (and fellow sex-worker) Nagisa: she was the best thing in the movie.
Rin Takanashi, Tadashi Okumno, Ryo Kase, Denden, Mihoko Suzuki, Reiko Mori
A slow moving (but elegiac) film that builds to a powerful and unexpected twist. Sartika is a young pregnant woman fleeing her family for reasons we are not given ("On Your Lap" does not offer many explanations). She stumbles into a small tea shop run by Maya who sees someone in need and takes her in without question. Sartika is willing to work; she cleans house for Maya at first, works in the fields, and finally, at Maya's suggestion, serves coffee to guests and sits on the laps of male customers while massaging their shoulders (a service known as "kopi pangku" in Indonesia). That's all that goes on here, though it is implied that there is more going on in other coffee shops. Her son is born and she continues to work at the coffee shop where she meets Hadi, a truck driver, who begins to fall for her and seems a remarkably nice man. Perhaps he really is, but at this point in the film you are beginning to enjoy an unusually optimistic but detailed examination of the life of the working poor in Indonesia. There are developments that are unexpected but not shocking; a development so well-engineered that in retrospect it seemed inevitable. It's not a perfect movie: the dialogue at times seem rote, and there are two instances of music intruding on the narrative that I wished had been left out. The acting is good. And I loved the way director Rahadian lets the camera film a long scene from a static position while we see actors move in and out of view and hear dialogue. We see the details of life among the poor here: the furnishings, the stove, the delight when someone offers a free fish or two for dinner. There is, above all, a sense of the fragility of the stable security Sartika achieves for a time. We sense that she is never far from a disaster but that isn't milked for cheap suspense: it's a condition of her world. This is a beautiful, lovely film.
Claresta Taufan Kusumarina, Fedi Nuril, Christine Hakim, Shakeel Fauzi, Devano Danendra, Jose Rizal Manua
Two-part extended interviews with Wade Robson and Jimmy Safechuck, and family and friends, two men who claim that they were sexually exploited by Michael Jackson as young children. Disturbing on multiple levels, including the fact that both men sued the Jackson estate in 2013-2014 after Jackson's death (both lost initially for technical reasons but a new date, February 2028, has been set on appeal). A third case was settled out of court for an amount said to be in the millions. As someone who always found Michael Jackson perverse for other reasons-- his surgeries, his craven obsession with celebrity culture, his materialism, his infatuation with other celebrities like Princess Diana and Elizabeth Taylor, his self-pitying take on his own childhood, his manipulate public gestures of kindness to children-- I am ambivalent about the documentary. I note also that while one could or should admire the technical virtuosity of some of his hits, I never thought there was much to his music aside from sound bites. I found his projection of himself as "bad" or "dangerous" comically unpersuasive. Would he have been a decent human being if the allegations were untrue? No. But "Leaving Neverland" resonates beyond the basic charges. It's about celebrity culture itself: the families of both Safechuck and Robson were awed by Jackson's kindness to them-- and financial benefits-- and by his status as a kind of god of celebrityhood. They were invited to his "Neverland" ranch and his other residences, driven around in limousines or flown to tour dates, cuddled and smothered with Jackson's largesse to the point where they were blind to what should have been incredibly obvious. Even if some of the claims of sexual activity are untrue or exaggerated, the fact that Jackson had the boys share his bed-- a 30-year-old man cuddling with a seven-year-old boy-- is bizarre. It is also conspicuous that defenders of Jackson did not limit themselves to "I never experienced abuse", which they are qualified to say, but went further and alleged that he didn't abuse anyone, which they could not, of course, know. Both of the boys, Safechuck and Robson, defended Jackson in court, under oath (thereby facilitating the abuse of other children who did go public). Jackson eventually married Priscilla Presley and then Debbie Rowe (an employee) with whom he had two children before divorcing her also. The interviews in "Leaving Neverland" are stately paced, perhaps even boring at times, but also cumulatively compelling. Joy Robson in particular is revealed to be infatuated with Jackson's aura to the point where she thought of him like a son, and emerges as particularly complicit. We note how the boys were crushed when Jackson moved on to other victims, even when he desperately tried to revive the relationships when he needed their testimonies in court. The film is lavishly enriched with video of Jackson performing (he is always performing, especially at personal appearances) and with tastefully affecting musical settings for drone footage of Neverland and other residences.
Wade Robson, Jimmy Safechuck, Joy Robson, Shane Robson, Stephanie Safechuck, Michael Jackson
Stylish gangster joke beautifully filmed and acted (for the most part) and clever but-- is there really anything substantive to it? It's a bit of a character study, but not enough to offset the pervasive use of cliche and gangster movie tropes. Sure they're all having fun, and there's some entertaining gore, but is it really meaty enough to justify its heraldic esteem? Gabriel Byrne mumbles his way through Tom Reagan, a free-lance mobster right-hand man working for Leo O'Bannon, an Irish mobster, who is dating Verna. Verna's brother, Bernie Bernbaum, appears to be cheating a rival gangster, Johnny Casper, out of some gambling money, and Casper wants him killed but Leo is understandably reluctant. Tom, of course, is having an affair with Verna. They talk to each other like credible but not fresh copies of Bogart and Bacall. When Leo finds out, all hell breaks loose. The cops and the mayor are so compromised by the gangs that they perform as servants of the bosses, but not without a smidgeon of self-respect. Tom is kind of a nihilist: everybody lies and nobody really cares about anyone but themselves. The plot is clever with double-double crosses and some unpredictability, but the ending is a bit preposterous: Tom is relying on an outcome I didn't think was all that predictable, and which could result in disaster. John Turturro is impressive as Bernie.
Gabriel Byrne, Albert Finney, John Turturro, Marcia Gay Harden, Jon Polito, J. E. Freeman, Mike Starr, Al Mancini, Richard Woods, Tom Toner, Steve Buscemi, Mario Todisco
Very long-winded, occasionally tedious, portrait of a group of journalists (mostly women) trying to preserve independent media in Russia during the years just before and during the Ukraine invasion of 2022. Filmed by Loktev on an Apple Iphone, we spend a lot of time following Ksenia Mironova, Sonya Groysman, Irinia Dolinia and the others as they meet for coffee, eat meals, and, mostly, cover the news from an independent station TV Rain, broadcast on Youtube. In the first half, they are wary and determined but seem generally free to circulate and report on protests and political prisoners. But in the second half, Putin has invaded Ukraine and TV Rain is block by the authorities and there is a real imininent threat of incarceration for all of the journalists working there. They are a likeable group, mostly lesbians (Mironova's fiancé had been imprisoned before the timeline of the film-- and was eventually sentenced to 20 years), smart, articulate, and very committed to free and tolerant society (of LGBQT rights, among other things). They joke around, they smoke, they party, and they despair of ever getting rid of Putin. They talk about how life was considerably more free during the brief tenure of Medvedev-- I had no idea-- and about the possibility of having to flee Russia, and where they would go. The most moving moments come when Ksenia Mironova realizes she will have to leave even with her fiancé, Ivan, in prison. You really sense the impact of dramatic changes to their lives, their sudden distance from friends and home, with no immediate prospect of return. It's a terrific film in many ways but I doubt it would have suffered much from some editing: there a long stretches in which very little action takes place: just conversations, in cars or apartments, or the faces of the journalists as they work on computers in the offices of TV Rain. It is also clearly about themselves and I would have liked a bit more actual reporting on the state of Russian society and culture at the time. That said-- it's not really boring. And you certainly take away from it a familiarity with an very under-reported world: the inside story of Russian dissent.
Olga Churakova, Irina Dolinina, Sonya Groysman, Elena Kostyuchenko, Alesya Marokhovskaya, Ksenia Mironova, Anna Nemzer, Daniil Sotnikov
Martha Hoffman's two daughters, Olga and Myriam, want to lock her up. They are concerned about her reckless self-indulgence, her bohemian tastes, her shady friends (who they think are stealing her money or artworks). They persuade a psychiatrist to admit her to a home take control of her finances and property. The court appoints Leandro Casares (Daniel Hendler, who also wrote and directed the film) to investigate their claims and determine if Martha is competent to manage her own affairs. Leandro has his own issues: he has problems holding on to relationships, and he still lives with his somewhat interfering father. He's uptight, but, again, this is not a caricature. This off-beat film-- based on a true story (of Argentine artist and writer Natalia Kohen) avoids the obvious Hollywood tropes and delivers a refreshing, meandering exploration of issues around competence and aging and exercising your passion for living life fully according to your own preferences and inclinations. The true story also inspired the Argentine government to revise the law governing commitments of people against their will. Martha is charming and funny and Leandro is played straight, reacting to her eccentricities with believable judiciousness and indulgence (she persuades him to stretch himself). Lovely sequence at some kind of artists community inside an old warehouse where they sculpt, play music, dance, take drugs, and make love. Martha is refreshingly sensible on most levels, and not caricatured as you would think the typical Hollywood treatment would offer. Not a great film, but a good one.
Marilu Marini, Daniel Hendler, Humberto Tortonese, Julieta Zylberberg, Paula Grinszpan, Carla Peterson
Over-rated "drama" about a group of British Customs and Excise agents press into address the drug crisis in Britain, in the 1990's. How close to the real story? Not very. There are lots of scenes of nail-biting tension (if you believe in them) that are surely invented. Then there are skips in the narrative where we are supposed to fill in important detail about events we don't see. Guy Stanton, and the others, are constantly suspected of being plants and threatened in ways that don't make sense from the point of view of the criminals. For one thing, even for drug dealers, murder is not considered so quickly for every dubious relationship-- we know from real journalism that more often they simply drop the relationship or shut people out. At one point the undercover agents buy heroin in Afghanistan and provide a boat to deliver it to England, which raises questions of entrapment (certainly in the U.S.). Many of the characters-- it is acknowledged-- are "composites", and, therefore, so is a lot of drama. We do know that in real life Declan Carter (real name: Curtis Warren) walked away (mocking the police as he did) when the court case fell apart.
Tom Burke, Steve Coogan, Hayley Squires, Aml Ameen, Jasmine Blackborow, Douglas Hodge, Gerald Kyd, Numan Acar, Charlotte Ritchie, Tom Hughes
From IMDB trivia: "One person who reacted warmly to the film was Ayatollah Khomeini". Director, Dariush Mehrjui, was murdered in 2023 (October 14), along with his wife by a disgruntled former employee. Is this a great film? It is austere, black and white, unconventional, original, and carries that patina of earthbound proletarian sensibility. I don't think that makes it a great film, though it is an interesting film. Hassan, brilliantly acted by Ezzatolah Entezami, is the only man in a small town who owns a cow, which he adores, with a rather intense passion. We see him bathing the cow in a river, laughing, caressing it. It's almost a bit creepy. There are three mysterious figures who appear on the horizon several times, and sneak into the village at one point. The villagers believe they are trying to steal the cow, and have stolen sheep. One day, Hassan has to go to the city for an errand and leaves the cow in the care of his wife and the village. The cow dies for unknown reasons and the villagers, knowing that Hassan is extremely passionate about his dear cow, are in a panic about what to do. They finally settle on lying to Hassan, telling him that the cow ran away. Hassan returns and quickly detects the lies and falls into a devastating funk. He refuses to come out of his barn and begins eating hay and behaving like a cow. Eventually the village decides to take him to a hospital in a nearby town. That's about it. The town exists in a harsh, bereft plain, of mud huts and a large pool and a few trees. The people of the town don't appear to have any particular jobs or tasks to do: the men, in particular, hang around having tea and discussing what to do about Hassan. There is a subplot about an relationship between a young couple considering marriage. There is a village idiot who is chained in a shed somewhere to keep him from revealing the fate of the cow to Hassan. I don't think there is enough there to lift the film into greatness and I'm not sure there is even the consolation prize of learning a lot about a distant, alien culture. But, well, Khomeini liked it.
Ezzatolah Entezami, Mahin Shahabi, Ali Nasirian, Jamshid Mashayekhi, Ezzatollah Ramazanifar
Daniel Miller finally acquires the car of his dreams only to have a head-on collision with a bus (while groping for a CD that fell to the floor). He dies and goes a place of transition, "Judgement City", where a panel of two judges are to decide if he should "advance" in life or go back. The criteria apparently is having the guts or courage to take chances and seize opportunities. He is defended by a bland "lawyer", Bob Diamond, and prosecuted by an unpleasant Lena Foster, who tries to prove that Daniel left potential greatness on the table by retreating in moments when he could have acted decisively to his advantage. Yes, you thought they were looking for moments of virtue, or kindness, or intelligence? No, this is the Ayn Rand school of transition, and given the premises of the movie, one should be an asshole to advance in life. Some of the scenarios include bullying, wherein he refused to beat up the bully, and failure to give a speech at a convention of advertising executives. Seriously. There is nothing funny or playful or inventive here, and the jokes a dull-witted and delivered with decisive banality. The supporting cast looks like they are warming up for something more interesting coming later. Meryl Streep gives it her best as the love interest but I wasn't convinced until it was too late and the movie was almost over. The only way the final scenes could have worked would have been if she and Albert Brooks had developed a convincing rapport and affection for each other, but I couldn't see anything but Streep bouncing off the impenetrable wall of Brook's vacuous self-effacement. Picture a bad imitation of Woody Allen, without the charm. This is a concept that went nowhere, remained undeveloped and lifeless, and boring.
Albert Brooks, Meryl Streep, Rip Torn, Lee Grant, Roger Behr, George D. Wallace, Lillian Lehman, Buck Henry, Shirley MacLaine
If you think a book is magnificent and important you want to make a film from it, them film the fucking book! This version of "Lord of the Flies", however, is a cinematic remora, leeching itself onto a brilliant, controversial novel, and then imposing the screen-writer and director's half-baked psychological tropes onto the characters. Yes, the boys are being evacuated by plane when it crashes on an island (miraculously, the boys are alive and well-- only the pilot is killed-- and none of the boys-- remarkably-- have any serious injuries) and the sensible Ralph is elected leader and the cynical Jack is leader of the choir and makes them hunters. Simon, the clairvoyant, is there, and Roger the sadist, and Samanderic. And of course, representing science-- unpleasantly-- there is Piggy. The most egregious fault in this version is displayed when Piggy is hit by a rock and instead of dying-- his brains smashed-- Ralph drags him into the jungle and the two share a long meaningful and therapeutic chat before he dies. We discover his real name-- something never revealed in the book. Why? It's readily apparent: a misguided effort to add contrived emotional weight to his friendship with Ralph. Some critics thought this worked and found it touching. I found it contrary to the meaning and content of the book: there is a significant point about the fact that Ralph isn't really all that nice to Piggy: like the others, he finds him obtuse and weak, though he realizes he needs Piggy's smarts. This modification undermines the story. We also get backstory-- seriously? Did the writer really take Golding's indictment of human nature and try to turn it into a story of how repressed trauma can make you do very, very naughty things? In this version, Simon doesn't see the truth and is murdered for it; Simon just stumbles into a sloppy dance party and is kind of accidentally clubbed to death. Does writer Thorne have the slightest clue of what "Lord of the Flies" is about? And of course we get diversity: Ralph is half black and there are other blacks and even Orientals among the boys. I might have respected the effort if they had had the audacity make Jack black (like Judas in "Jesus Christ Superstar"-- the most colorblind casting decision I can think of) but it's Ralph and Winston Sawyers is not a strong enough actor to make the character resonate. Speaking of which: David McKenna as Piggy is remarkable, as is Ike Talbut as Simon. Jack is a juicy role but I'm not sure what to make of Lox Pratt's take on it. Now, all that aside, the series does have some extraordinarily brilliant cinematography, and some excellent ensemble moments, with a lot of very young boys looking suitably alarmed and disheveled or indifferent. That works. But the island in this version has no geography: just random areas that appear and disappear as required by the utility of the scene. The boys go into the jungle, swim in a pool, climb rocks, hang out at the beach, but none of seems to be of a single place or even time. I could not give you any idea of how big this island is supposed to be in the film.
Winston Sawyers, Lox Pratt, David McKenna, Ike Talbut, Thomas Connor, Cornelius Brandreth
Not your "Back to the Future" with it's cloying contrivances. Peggy Sue faints at her high school's 25th reunion in 1985 and wakes up in 1960. To us, she looks the same, but everyone around her sees her as the 18-year-old she was then, which is clever and sidesteps some artistic problems with the concept. She openly says things that make sense to her and shouldn't make sense to her family and friends but they react as I think they would if this happened in real life: they are so engaged in the immediacy of her presence that they don't see the problem. Besides, many of her comments are ambiguous given the situations she is in. She and Charlie are about to get divorced (he cheated on her) in 1985 so here's an opportunity for her to re-examine the feelings that got her into the marriage in the first place. And an opportunity to apply her hard-won wisdom to situations that she only engaged with as a naive teenager the first time. Wonderfully, her friends in high school are more than cutouts or stereotypes. Even the class nerd, Richard, is presented as a complex, justly grievanced character, whom she likes and defends (as the mature Peggy Sue). She also gets an opportunity to indulge her lust for wanna-be Beatnik Michael Fitzsimmons (who should have been more interesting-- no interest in college?). She appreciates her parents and grand-parents with fresh enthusiasm and touchingly revels in the details of the period. There are flaws-- Michael's book dedication is presented with banal favor, as if there was nothing more interesting to be had there-- there should have been a lot!-- and Nicholas Cage's idiotic mannerisms are off-putting and cost credibility in terms of the romance-- what does she see in the lug? Even worse, Charlie's sudden remorse and declarations of eternal love just ring hollow and seem tailored more to viewer predisposition than story integrity. One of the things "Peggy Sue Got Married" does well is touch on (without necessarily exploring) some issues with real emotional resonance: how do choices we make when we are young play out over a lifetime? How do we judge what we owe to the past?
Kathleen Turner, Nicholas Cage, Barry Miller, Catherine Hicks, Joan Allen, Kevin J. O'Connor, Jim Carrey, Lisa Jane Persky, Lucinda Jenney, Sofia Coppola, Barbara Harris, Don Murray, Helen Hunt
Wonderful miniseries (20 episodes) set in the Knickerbocker, a New York hospital in 1900, focused on the brilliant Dr. Thackery, a surgeon who boldly develops new techniques and procedures as the science of medicine, in it's infancy, plunges into a bold new world, while struggling with addiction to morphine and heroin. The plot weaves around Thackery and his fellow physicians, the racist Everett Gallinger, the earnest Bertie Chickering, and a negro trying to crack through it all, Algernon Edwards, a protege of the wealthy Robertson family who sponsor the hospital. Meanwhile, hospital executive Herman Barrow takes kick-backs, and ambulance driver Tom Cleary helps a nun, Sister Harriet, provide abortions to desperate young women. Based on real events and histories, beautifully immersive, beautifully filmed, and generally well-written (with the odd weaker episode). Nurse Elkins, played by Bono's daughter, Eve Hewson, who is Irish but does a convincing Georgia accent, is one of the more striking storylines: from a naive, idealistic, ingenue, wronged, and the object of love, she becomes one of the more complex, faulted characters in the series.
Clive Owen, Andre Holland, Jeremy Bobb, Juliet Rylance, Eve Hewson, Michael Angarano, Cara Seymour, Eric Johnson, Chris Sullivan, Grainger Hines, Maya Kazan, Yifa Edelstein, Tom Lipinski, Jennifer Ferrin, Charles Aitken
Louis Theroux investigates the manosphere, interviewing "influencers" like Harrison Sullivan, Ed Matthews, Justin Waller, and others, and some of their acolytes (inevitably young males). Theroux wisely plays a nice balance between curious investigator and voice of mainstream morality, while confronting the most incredibly retrograde cultural values imaginable. It seems surprising that they would invite him into their homes, but that's part of their currency: a fearless devotion to "shock" and defiance of cultural norms, though Harrison, when is wife is present, appears to back down somewhat. Most of them hold that the male in a partner relationship should be free to pursue as many women as he likes, while the woman is expected to be monogamous. And to give up her career to cook and clean and have babies. All of them appear to getting rich by selling various get-rich schemes and services to gullible followers. They all also appear to be fudging details of their personal histories. Some of them appear to be Christian (one of them became a Muslim) and they all adore Donald, of course. The virulent anti- Semitism of course rears its ugly head. Is this really ascendant in our culture, or is it just a selective coterie of incels and losers?
Justin Waller, Louis Theroux, Harrison Sullivan, Kacey May, Ed Matthews, Matty, Angie Camacho, Stirling Cooper, Kristen Waller, Sneako
Two couples and one threesome, in Memphis, reacting to Elvis everywhere, dealing with dislocation, wonder, and despair. Jun and Mitzuko are a Japanese couple come to honor Elvis and Carl Perkins and Sun Studio, and generously impressed by the blank, wasted, desolate landscape of Memphis-- vacant lots, abandoned movie theatres, and ailanthus trees. Luisa is from Italy, freshly widowed (we don't know what happened), carrying a lot of money, wary of some men who appear dangerous to her, and smart. She meets Dee-Dee who is fleeing her stubborn boyfriend, and they decide to share a hotel room in a seedy downtown hotel. Johnny is Dee-Dee's stubborn boyfriend, freshly laid off along with his friend, Charlie, hanging out at a bar with Will Robinson, drinking heavily. They all end up in the Arcade Hotel, changing direction, looking for outs. It's not really about the events here: it's the atmosphere, the Elvis culture, the desperation and naivete, where Memphis is a state of wasted mind and exhausted cultural touchstones-- Sun Studios and Graceland and Elvis' portrait in every hotel room. All wonderfully accented by John Lurie's excellent soundtrack, a kind of simplified drawl of early rhythm and blues.
Masatoshi Nagase, Yuki Kudo, Screamin' Jay Hawkins, Cinque Lee, Nicoletta Braschi, Elizabeth Brackko, Tom Noonan, Stephen Jones, Joe Strummer, Rick Aviles, Steve Buscemi, Tom Waits
Where is this going? I hesitate to classify this as a comedy because it's not very funny, though it tries (the absurd tennis matches!). Lacking the charm or impetus of "Once" or "The Commitments", "The Ballad of Wallis Island" should have been able to rely on the musical charm of the putative artists here, Tom Basden as Herb McGwyer and Carey Mulligan as Nell Mortimer. But if there was musical talent to be had in those two it isn't visible here (much as the two leads of "Mighty Wind" fall flat in that regard). Herb and Nell used to be a folk duo whose work deeply inspired Charles Heath, who also happened to win the lottery, twice. Charles uses his lavish resources to invite Herb to his island to put on a concert without telling him that he has also invited Nell. He wants them to do a reunion concert, hoping to bring them back together. Charles, a compulsive talker, is quite flakey so his motives are sometimes mixed. And clearly Herb and Nell had an unpleasant break-up. Herb, it seems, is open to reigniting the flames, but Nell is not. And there is no concert prepared-- just a couple of pallets on the beach. No audience. Not even proper equipment. Tom Basden isn't convincing as a career musician, nor is Carey Mulligan. The makes of the movie seem aware of this: the music is actually minimal. There is a token romance between Charles and Amanda, the store owner (who hilariously--we are told-- offers a jar of peanut butter to Nell because she doesn't have any Reese's Peanut Butter Cups). Even if you buy it as a comedy, it's just not very funny.
Tom Basden, Tim Key, Carey Mulligan, Sian Clifford
Maria "Cabiria" Ceccarelli is an impish prostitute in Rome's Parco di Porta Capena. She is funny, loud, abrasive, and sometimes charming. This is about survival on the streets for poor women with no other options, though Cabiria owns her own house and , as is apparent by the end, has assets. And she has a community of fellow hookers, interested men, regular customers, and the church. She joins a parade led by priests and nuns, and goes to a church to pray for a miracle from the virgin Mary. She meets a famous actor who invites her to his home but is interrupted when his angry girlfriend returns begging to reconcile. She attends a show at a theatre where the mentalist hypnotizes her on stage and persuades her to dance and rhapsodize about a fictional lover named Oscar. Then she meets a real Oscar and is swept away until reality comes crashing down again. Giulietta Masina is brilliant, of course, an extraordinary actress, who does put you off at times because she is so authentic. Her expressiveness, in both her face and body, is mesmerizing. The crowd scenes are extraordinary, and the range of complex characters is rich and evocative of the era. A really extraordinary film. Note: "Sweet Charity" with Shirley Maclaine was based upon this film. But, of course, only after being neutered.
Giulietta Masina, Francois Perier, Franca Marzi, Dorian Gray, Aldo Silvani
A really extraordinary film in many respects. Firstly, Duvall wrote the entire screenplay himself, in long-hand, but could not persuade a single studio to take it on. He ended up financing it himself for about $5 million with some other investors. When it was shown at Toronto's film festival, the studios immediately bid on it. Duvall says he is a believer and was always fascinated with Pentecostal ministers and their charismatic "performances", the swaying and singing and call and response, and his performance here is also extraordinary. The congregants are a combination of actors and actual church-goers from churches Duvall had visited while researching another role. Duvall plays Sonny Dewey, later known as The Apostle E.F.. His wife, Jessie, is cheating on him with a youth pastor, Horace, at and it is clear that Sonny has cheated on her earlier. Sonny casually asserts that he role as evangelist gives him wiggle room on such issues. The church votes to fire him, and Sonny confronts Horace at his son's baseball game and assaults him, forcing him to flee. He drives his car into a lake and travels by various means until he reaches a small town in Louisiana where he strikes up a relationship with a retired local pastor who has an abandoned church to offer. Gradually, Sonny builds a new church community. White people in the town think he is black, after hearing him on the radio; the blacks know he is white but with his charisma wins them over the church is soon full. These are the most remarkable scenes in the film, the worship services, the improvisation, the way Sonny keeps things moving, the mesmerizing repetition. It's a rare close-up look at a segment of Americana we rarely see (or which is most often caricatured). Sonny hits on Toonsie without a hint of moral ambivalence: it's right because I do it and God will still love me because I am his vessel. He starts selling scarves that he has "personally blessed", on the radio. The radio host is played wonderfully as a believer who hasn't lost his reason quite yet and knows good line when he hears one. We don't sense judgment of Sonny when he hits on Toonsie or sells the scarves and one wonders if Duvall really believes that there's something about Sonny that is genuine in a good sense. I don't think he would even wonder if there was anything wrong about mixing commerce with religion-- why not? Or how aware he is of how Sonny, the way he is dramatized, is a user. He uses people especially when he thinks he is holiest: testifying to them, nagging them about committing to Christ, manipulating them. One can't doubt that, given enough time, Sonny would have built himself a mansion and acquire a private jet for his personal use, and never once doubted that God would want him to have it. It's a great film with one notable flaw: the long sermon he leads at the end, as the police tactfully wait for him to finish, is too long. What is entertaining about watching him preach is not the preaching itself, but the actor channeling a real thing into art. When it goes on too long, one realizes that Duvall wants us to see the preaching itself, and the preaching itself is so full of artifice and the entire schtick is so absurd that it becomes tedious when stretched. The other problem is that Duvall was 66 when he made the film and his performance is outstanding but the role clearly called for someone 20 years younger, and when he hits on poor Miranda Richardson as "Toonsie", it is very hard to suspend your disbelief.
Robert Duvall, Todd Allen, John Beasley, June Carter Cash, Farrah Fawcett, Rick Dial, Walton Goggins, Miranda Richardson, Billy Joe Shaver, Billy Bob Thorton
Marcello is an ambitious Italian man in 1938 Rome who wants nothing more than to be "normal". So he marries a good Catholic girl, Giulia, goes to confession, and joins the secret police attached to the government of Mussolini. "The Conformist" a study of the fascist psychology, how the desire to be part of something large and coherent drives the actions of young men without the ability to develop an independent consciousness or morality. Marcello is recruited to murder his former professor, Quadri, who recognizes the fascist in Marcello but thinks he can enlighten him. Quadri's wife, the beautiful Anna, falls in love with Marcello, for no reason the film gives us, and with Giulia. We are told the story in flashbacks, including the story of how Marcello was sexually abused by a young chauffeur whom he thinks he has killed with the chauffeur's pistol (which he used to entice the young Marcello into his bed). He confesses it all to a priest who absolves him because he is doing holy work for Mussolini. Marcello's friend, the blind Italo, also works for Mussolini, as a radio producer and broadcaster, and mentors Marcello. Marcello's mother is a morphine addict and his father has lost his mind and resides in an institution which he visits. It is all filmed in stunning, gorgeous color by Victorio Storaro, but the dramatic scenes often seem stilted and drawn-out, and even clumsy. The murder of Quadri has to be the most clumsy assassination ever staged on film, and even there Marcello is voyeur, watching disinterestedly from a car that has followed the professor into a secluded wooded area. When Anna runs to him to beg for her life, he looks away. Later, he hears of Mussolini's downfall on the radio (1943, I take it, before the Nazis restored him) while spending the evening in his normal home with his daughter. He goes out and while a passing mob sings the "Internationale" he denounces his old friend Italo as a fascist, and spots the chauffeur trying to seduce a young man. The chauffeur flees and it is Marcello who seduces the young man revealing that his sexual appetite is as conformist, in a way, as his politics. A strange film redeemable mainly for the excellent cinematography.
Jean Louis Trintignant, Dominique Sanda, Stefania Sandrelli, Gastone Moschin, Enzao Tarascio, Pirre Clementi, Jose Quaglio, __ Milly
Okay, it's very slight, 76 minutes, nothing more than a conversation between two actors representing Peter Hujar, a New York photographer-artist who died in 1987 at 53 of AIDS, and Linda Rosenkrantz, a writer. The transcript of the conversation was "lost" for forty years and then, after rediscovery, was scripted for this film. It's an engaging film, moderately interesting, prosaically presented. It is "Peter" telling Linda everything he could remember about everything he did the day before, which included photographing Allen Ginsberg, sleeping, making meals, having conversations. Nothing spectacular. All of it charmingly re-enacted by Ben Whishaw and especially Rebecca Hall, who conveys a remarkably compelling sense of attentiveness, interest, encouragement, and tasteful restraint throughout. That's what I remember most about the film: the vanity free presence of "Linda", committed, for the duration, of being an interested listener, occasionally remarking on her opinion that Peter needed to eat better and smoke less.
Ben Whishaw, Rebecca Hall
As is often the case, when the star is also a producer, we get an unbalanced film, tilted towards sequences feature the inestimable gifts of the producer-actor, and tilted away some of the potentially more interesting ideas. Even worse: to secure the cooperation of other F1 racing teams, producer Jerry Bruckheimer had to promise not to portray any of them "negatively". So, no real drama. But when your entire film consists of one cliche after another, who needs drama? And of course the stars did some of their own driving. And we have a woman technical director when not a single woman has ever been an F1 technical director. Pitt was 63 at the time of filming; his romantic interest, Kerry Condon, was 43. Well, better than the usual. And note this: Lewis Hamilton is the ONLY black F1 driver in its entire history (770+ drivers). Co-screenwriter Ehren Kruger (and others) are veterans of the tedious Top Gun movies. The most interesting thing about the film is way it reflects the standard configuration of American cultural tropes: Pitt, the American, is more earthy, realistic, and humble than his European counterparts. He is contemptuous of the media (and the film caters to that prejudice by ridiculing an F1 journalist and having Pitt show his disdain for the very constituency that makes the fabulously expensive F1 system possible: the media). Hayes also mocks the science behind the racing cars (because his own red-neck American intuition is superior) but then helps research design changes: having it both ways. He also cheats in a way we are led to believe is kind of ingenious, though obviously other racers would do it too if it really worked. Some of his tricks are blatantly illegal and, in the real world, would result in permanent expulsion from F1 championships. And, ridiculously, Hayes begins competing in F1 races after a 30 year absence without any lead-in period of training or qualification: simply can't happen. But we are expecting too much from this confection. Even Pitt and Bardem look disinterested in their parts. Pitt looks too old (he IS too old) for the part. And certainly ridiculously too old to be competitive in an F1 race. We also get one of the oldest trick in the Hollywood book: Hayes cannot be perceived to want to race in F1, because he is ambitious, or wants to make money, or wants babes. No, no: he must be dragged kicking and screaming into the race, so we can have a kind of martyrdom aspect to his sufferings. Furthermore, he must be able to behave very badly, costing the team money and position, without consequence, when, in real life, he would certainly have been fired immediately. And having an affair with the team's technical director? Not a problem in this movie. And replacing a driver at qualification at a race at the last minute: no contract issues? No rules infringements?
Brad Pitt, Damson Idris, Javier Bardem, Kerry Condon, Tobias Menzies, Kim Bodnia, Sarah Niles
Searing documentary focused on an activist, Lizzie Hershberger, a former Mennonite who was sexually abused by her father and uncles. The stunning part of this documentary, which features interviews with many survivors of sexual abuse (who mostly have left the Mennonite or Amish communities), is how shockingly widespread it is, and how the communities continue to try to compel the victims to "be quiet and forgive" rather than report the abuse to the police and authorities. As a rule, the men continue in their positions and social status after conviction. Numerous friends and relatives plead with the judge for leniency. Some nice visuals of the Mennonite farms, buggies, and people. A bit self-serving at the end when Hershberger is effusively praised for her work which, it is suggested but not directly shown, has led to numerous convictions. It was an unnecessary exercise and raised questions in my mind about the objectivity of the film. One commentator observed that if all the abusers in the Mennonite community were reported, 80% of the men would be in jail. Hershberger received many abusive messages via email and Facebook for her work. The Amish use Facebook?
Lizzie Hershberger, Elizabeth Hilty, Katrina Weaver, Menno Yoder, Rachel Hawley
Adolph Eichmann looked so much like just about anyone that for fifteen years he was able to hide from the Nazi-hunters without great difficulty, living in a house in Argentina, working for Mercedes-Benz, raising a family, attending meetings of sympathetic former and present Nazis. Mossad found him through information from a girl-friend of his son, Karl, kidnapped him, and shipped him to Israel for trial. Eichmann famously claimed to only be following orders, was convicted and hanged in June 1962. "Finale" has a marvelous subject with great potential, but the mechanics of the plot are banal and the actors often fall into rote recitations of information they want the viewer to have. Yet, there are a few compelling moments, in the dialogue between Eichmann and Peter Malkin, in which Malkin accuses Eichmann of believing the Jews were animals and Eichmann says we are all animals. On the other hand, Kingsley was 74 at the time of filming; Eichmann was 54 at the time of his capture. The difference does matter. Kingsley does well with what he has, but still, it does influence our perception of Eichmann's personality and attitudes.
Oscar Isaac, Ben Kingsley, Melanie Laurent, Lior Raz, Nick Kroll, Michael Aronov, Ohad Knoller, Joe Alwyn, Greta Scacchi, Haley Lu Richardson, Peter Strauss
The Shakers were a diverting odd subsect of Protestantism that thrived briefly and on a small scale in 18th Century England and then moved (as a result of persecutions) to New England in 1774. They found land and farmed and lived communally while continuing to evangelize in the colonies experiencing some growth (up to 18 communities and 3,000 to 4,000 adherents) until fading out by late in the 19th Century. They danced and sang during worship and women assumed leadership roles alongside the men. Ann Lee became recognized as the reincarnation of Jesus Christ and was called "Mother Ann". One impediment to growth: they saw all sexual activity as sinful and called upon their followers to live in chaste relationships (though they did allow adoptions). "Testament" is sometimes almost magical in the integration of music and dance and swirling camera work and beautiful cinematography. They were among the first conscientious objectors in American history (recognized as such by Lincoln).
Amanda Seyfried, Lewis Pullman, Thomasin McKenzie, Matthew Beard, Christopher Abbot, Viola Prettejohn, David Cale, Stacy Martin
Powerful, sweeping docudrama about the uprising in Algiers under French domination in the late 1950's. Filmed using almost all non-professionals, and, apparently, no documentary footage (which you may find hard to believe-- a compliment to the film). It was filmed in Algiers with the support of the Algerian government, and it is perceived as mostly pro-Algerian though the French police and military are not portrayed as stereotypical oppressors or villains. Riveting action sequences with voluminous extras; large crowds and army groups. Beautifully filmed and generally well-acted even with the non-professionals. Was not permitted to be shown in France until 1971. An acclaimed film on many top 100 lists.
Brahim Hadjadj, Jean Martin, Yacef Saadi, Samia Kerbash, Ugo Paletti, Fouzia El Kader, Mohamed Ben Kassen, Si Mohamed Baghdadi, Franco Morici, Neri Tommaso
Short film about a society in which things are purchased by receiving a slap, and all intimate contact is forbidden, including kissing. Angine, however, wants to kiss Malaise, who keeps making bigger and bigger purchases at Angine's counter in order to promote intimacy. Serious violators are bound, gagged, and thrown off a cliff in a cardboard box. Angine dares to come to Malaise's apartment but loses her courage, shortly before Malaise is exposed and condemned. Thin premise, professionally executed, and, I suppose, strikingly evocative of a society that is seriously ambivalent about human intimacy.
Zar Amir Ebrahimi, Luana Bajrami, Aurelie Boquien
Pavel Talankin worked as an "Event Coordinator" at the largest school in the Russian town of Karabash (pop. 10,000). When the war on Ukraine begins, his school received directives from Moscow ordering it to begin a program of propaganda to teach the children that war is good, Ukraine and the west are evil, the war is Ukraine's fault, and dissent harms the motherland. Talankin initially quits his job in protest but then decides to resume his position so he can document the state's intrusion and the kind of propaganda being foisted upon the teachers and students. After graduation a few years later, he flees with his footage and, with co-editor Borenstein, turns it into an interesting documentary. I would dispute the title: there's no polarity between Talankin and Putin. And Talankin is actually able to get away with being relatively openly dissenting while working at the school and even organizing the graduation and giving a speech there. There's no bite to the opposition suggested by the title. But it is interesting to view propaganda in action, to see one of the worst proselytizers voted "teacher of the year" by the students-- a man who admits to Talankin that he admires Lavrentiy Beria--, and to consider the effects of this kind of propaganda on the population of Russia, which, polls show, is enthusiastically supportive of Putin's war even as casualties pile up. It should surprise no one that many of the same tendencies he documents in dictatorial Russia are showing up in Trump's America.
Pavel Talankin, Vladimir Putin, Galina Aleksandrovna, Pavel Abdulmanov, Yevgenia Vladimirovna
It is tempting to be kinder to this film than it deserves. It is a small film, filled with the gentle transactions of everyday life, concerned with real issues, and generally free of contrivance and hype. Unfortunately, it's not particularly well-acted (except perhaps by Jane Levy as Tammy) or directed or filmed. It is by the writer of "Junebug" (directed by Phil Morrison) but comes nowhere near the exquisite strengths of that film. Even the writing of "A Little Prayer" seems under-developed. Bill owns a prosperous business of some kind and his son, David, works for him, and flirts with Narcedalia, another staff member. Bill is concerned, especially since he gets along well with Tammy and respects her. David also seems to have a substance abuse problem-- or does he?-- it's not clear. Bill also has a daughter, Patti, who has left her husband (we never meet him) and moved back home with her daughter, Hadley. Bill is played sympathetically by David Strathairn which makes the character more sympathetic to us than he deserves: he's a controlling person and insinuates himself into David's affairs and even directly urges Tammy to act in a way that may be ill-advised. We don't think it's ill-advised because "A Little Prayer" has rigged the story: we think he's right because we are not going to be allowed to see any ambiguity in the information Bill receives about them. I thought his actions were dangerously intrusive and I thought Tammy or Patti might well have been justified in telling him to butt out. But the movie fails on a more basic level: his conversations with David and with Tammy don't seem nuanced or developed. They kind of read their lines to each other and one can sense that they haven't worked out what they are doing while listening other than listening. They have a conversation in a car or on a bench and it all seems kind of dry and rote. When Tammy relates an incident of violence, it sounds like a social worker's description of it instead of something that had an impact on her feelings about her relationship with David. The same applies to Narcedalia's argument about keeping her baby and the film seems to think nothing of the issue of an employer having a sexual relationship with a staff member. In spite of these short-comings, one must appreciate the sincerity of the attempt and the tastefulness of it's realization.
David Strathairn, Will Pullen, Jane Levy, Celia Weston, Dascha Polanco, Anna Camp, Billie Roy
Very, very strange-- almost unhinged-- sometimes horrifying in a cringe sense-- story about a Viet Nam vet named Mike Sardina who meets a woman doing Patsy Cline tributes named Claire and together with her forms a Neil Diamond tribute band. The partnership quickly becomes romantic as well and a curious aspect of the film is the way their own relationship seems rock steady, even through all the tribulations in their lives and career. They have some success in the Milwaukee area and even get to open a show for Eddie Vedder (who comes off as extremely gracious) and Pearl Jam. (Hilariously, they don't even know who Vedder is, and Vedder-- honorably-- is pleased they don't.) Then things start to go wrong, particularly when Claire gets hit by a car while gardening in their front yard. Things go from shabby to tragic to shabbier yet. Their kids yell at them, their money runs out, they go bankrupt, and the gigs dry up. Then there is a bit of come back until another tragedy strikes. It's a strange story but the strangest thing of all is that they are a tribute band to an artist who is himself a tribute to commercial factory pop. Neil Diamond's songs are laid bare for what they are: incredibly mediocre, banal pop confections that can't bear the weight of the emotion audiences-- and "Lightening and Thunder" project onto them. I doubt that the irony of the whole thing was intentional. I think Kohs really thought there was something touching about them living their dreams. (He followed them for years to make the film, and utilizes a lot of home videos shot by the Sardinas). But could he really have felt that way when they talked about eventually playing Vegas, or about Claire's dreams of doing Broadway? Claire is obese and unappealing (though she does well with Patsy Cline) and Mike refuses to take a real job when the gigs dry up. One marvels that the camera was left rolling during some of the sequences, particularly of the kids bellowing at them. Claire's mother is openly contemptuous of them. Their kids hate their smoking and their indolence and the messy house they live in. Claire's daughter gets pregnant and plans to give the baby up to adoption.
Mike Sardina, Claire Sardina, Eddie Vedder, Dana Cartwright, Rachel Cartwright, Tom D'Amato, Angelina Sardina
Quiet, non-judgmental documentary on mediums and psychics, focusing on three in particular, Sherrie Lynne, Michael Kim, and Ilka Pinheiro. All three have an artistic bent, seem unprepossessing, and behave somewhat like therapists. You can see what they're doing (if you are astute) and the film doesn't need to lay it out for you. There is even an animal medium. There are moments when you feel embarrassed for the psychic trying to guess-- badly-- who the client is trying to connect with. There is a striking conversation with a young woman whom the psychic doesn't realize, at first, is a former classmate, and she has come to talk to another classmate who committed suicide. There's not a whole lot of revelation and drama, but there is the quiet, dignified portrait of trusting, credulous people in need, in anguish at times, and being human.
Sherrie Lynne, Michael Kim, Ilka Pinheiro, Nikenya Hall, Per Erik Borja, Eugene Grygo, Phoebe Hoffman
No real dialogue and the thin tendrils of narrative are diffuse and amorphous, but a pleasurable view with many interesting sequences of Chinese life in the 21st century, from dances to riverboats on the Yangtze River, and demolitions of houses to make way for the Three Gorges Dam. Qiaoquiao is traveling to a town in China and texting a former lover, Bin-- we presume-- asking why he hasn't responded. She travels by train or boat or on foot through areas that alternate between shabby and spectacular. There is a brief scene in which she tries to leave a trailer and is restrained by a man looking at his phone. No further explanation is offered. There is bewildering sequence in a spa of some kind, and in which an older man seems to be demanding oral sex from an attendant. It's a collage of cuts and streams taken over 20 years without any coherent plan to make it into a film. Give it points because recent Chinese history and culture is interesting (if only for the utter vacancy of it all) and the scenery is compelling.
Tao Zhao, Zhubin Li, You Zhou, Changchu Xu
I don't think it took any effort-- if there was any-- to allude to Donald Trump with this powerful, violent document of the first years of Mussolini's rise to power, to the moment he more or less defied Italy's Parliament to indict him for crimes he essentially admitted to (including murder, torture, and intimidation). And they did nothing. Very good at representing (with reasonable accuracy) the complicated multivariate tendrils of early 20th century Italian politics, involving the church, socialists, communists, and the nascent Fascist party led by Mussolini. Mussolini, like Hitler, reach moments of crisis in which he conceivably would have backed down (and disappeared down the dustbin of history) had his opponents stepped up at the right moment. But the King (Victor Emmanuel III) and the church and the other political parties were terrified of public disorder and Mussolini and cravenly allowed him to abolish elections and become a dictator. "Mussolini: Son of the Century" is obviously influenced by contemporary standards: the women in Mussolini's life are given more than passing notice. His abused wife, witheringly desperate for his attention, his exploited staff, his long-time mistress Margherita Sarfatti-- no, not the one who died with him in 1945 (Claretta Petacci)-- but a wealthy Jewess who provided him with great advice, financial support, and credibility. She was, on her own, an esteemed editor and art critic. And eventually a victim of her own success: she had to flee Italy in 1938 once Hitler convinced Mussolini to pass antisemitic racial laws). Funky cinematography featuring rapid fire clips of black & white footage, extremely bloody gun shot and stabbing wounds, and deliciously odd musical accompaniment, from opera, to "Can't Help Falling in Love".
Luca Marinelli, Francesco Russo, Barbara Chichiarelli, Benedetta Cimatti, Federico Majorana, Lorenzo Zurzolo, Gaetano Bruno, Vincenzo Memolato, Cosima Centurioni, Alberto Astorri
Luis daughter, Mar, has disappeared in Morocco after attending a rave. Luis sets out with his son, Esteban, to find her. He rents a minivan, locates a rave, and begins asking around, handing out pictures of Mar. Someone suggests Mar may have gone to the next rave in a different location, so Luis and Esteban follow the group, leading to a series of misadventures and tragedies. Most of the actors in "Sirat" are non-professionals drafted from the streets, so to speak. One has no hand. Another has a prosthetic leg. They have tattoos and that wizened street-smart exterior that conveys authenticity and character. They have an uneasy relationship with Luis at the start, but when he needs help, they offer it, and they are sympathetic to his cause. Powerful film, raw, and unpredictable. There are long sequences of dance to the hypnotic, repetitious beat of rave music. And very long stretches of travel through flat dessert landscapes, with brief interactions with military troops on the move to prevent or start a coup. "Sirat" is a religious concept, the transition to the afterlife on a hair-thin road that can result in salvation or death.
Sergi Lopez, Bruno Nunez Arjona, Stefania Gadda, Joshua Liam Herderson, Richard Bigui Bellamy, Tonin Janvier, Jade Oukid, Ahmed Abbou
It's a compelling subject and there are some real scandals here but there is something off about this documentary on "medical devices": mechanical or technological things that serve medical functions. Focused primarily on the mesh product used to address flabby muscles in women who have had children, a birth-control device called the Essure which blocks fallopian tubes from admitting sperm, and hip replacements made of cobalt which can poison the patients. In each case, there is insufficient research and government over-sight as Republicans and some Democrats wish to be on the side of "innovation" and deregulation. But its not "60 Minutes" or the New York Times. There is an undue emphasis on personal stories of woe, heart-breaking images of individuals who suffered greatly, none of which advances the narrative but plays to the emotions. The problem is that anecdotal evidence can overshadow the possible benefits. In this case, the documentary may be right about Essure and the other products but one could easily imagine a documentary on the terrible consequences of vaccines by giving disproportionate play anecdotal stories of negative side-effects.
Jim Spencer, Jeanne Lenzer, Michael Carome, Angie Firmalino, Peter Firmalino, Gaby Avina, Ana Fuentes
The story is very simple: a film director and his young son, 11-year-old Bahman, set out to see if a child actor in one of his earlier movies ("Where is the Friend's House" - a real movie also by Kiarostami) has survived a devastating earthquake in northern Iran in June 1990 killing over 35,000 people. The director drives through miles and miles of devastation encountering people, oddly, who seem more concerned with washing clothes or dishes or watching a football (soccer) game. Life goes on. We luxuriate in his portraits of ordinary people, most of them of goodwill or neighborly helpfulness, all of them struggling to get by in extraordinary or ordinary circumstances. An utterly un-Hollywood film, elevating the ordinary and prosaic to mysterious beauty and contemplation.
Farhad Kheradmand, Pouya Payvar, Behrouz Abedini, Shahin Abzan, Ahmed Ahmedpoor, Babek Ahmedpoor, Ziba Babyi
Incredibly prosaic and picturesque film about a film crew and actors shooting some footage in a small town recently devastated by an earthquake, Koker, in northern Iran. Hossein is an actor and Tahereh is an actress and they play a couple who married shortly after the earthquake even though both of them lost many family members in the quake. The actor, Hossein, seems to have "really" lost 25 people in the quake. Hossein badly wants to marry Tahereh but Tahereh's remaining family (her mother and father died in the quake) consider Hossein beneath them. He relentless pursues Tahereh and she relentlessly refused to answer or acknowledge him. Meanwhile they act out the same scenes over and over again when they make small mistakes each time. Mrs. Shiva is the director's right hand woman: she picks up the actors and deals with their issues. They seem to be camping out in a nearby grove. There is an olive grove nearby. And it all has this home-made vibe without the disorder one associates with amateurs. Director Kargardan is professional and determined. and the rest of his crew is quietly competent.
Mohamad Ali Keshavarz, Farhad Kheradmand, Zarifeh Shiva, Hossein Rezai, Tahereh Ladanian, Ahmed Ahmedpoor, Babek Ahmedpoor
Mostly talking-head interview with Paul Reubens who created and lived "Pee-wee Herman" for many years before scandals derailed his career-- for a time. He has made a comeback to some extent. For a time, he suppressed his sexual identity (did anyone not know he was gay?) then came out, then suppressed it again. There was a real "scandal" (exposing himself in a porn theatre) and then a phony one. The documentary doesn't lay it on too thick: yes he was inventive and funny and talented, but he wasn't a revolutionary genius like Chaplin or Keaton, or a real actor like Sellers. Interesting and illuminating.
Paul Reubens, Matt Wolf, Richard Gilbert Abramson, Prudence Fenton, Gary Panter, Laurence Fishburne, Abby Rubenfeld, Lynne Marie Stewart
Compelling if uneven story about an adolescent boy, Ben, at a summer camp for water polo. He fits in, kind of, but notes another boy, Eli, with a conspicuous rash whom the other boys shun as having an infectious "plague". The boys seem to know it isn't really the plague and it isn't really contagious but when he tries to join them at lunch they immediately desert the table. Astutely highlights the pressures of adolescent, the overweening need to fit in, to be cool. In this situation, status seems conferred by Jake (brilliantly played by Kayo Martin), who is complex and smart but capable of emotional and physical brutality. Ben eventually reaches out to Eli, at the expense of his own position, and the derision of the other boys. Adults, as always, are ineffectual and distant. Jake bullies Ben and mocks him after he has a wet dream and the two clash in water polo leading to consequences for Jake. Exceptionally well-filmed and acted, funky music, clever, well-edited, yet the I found the conclusion unsatisfying. I think the director - writer wanted a splashy ending, a significant incident to give it a bang and I think he over-reached. What might have been a stronger meditation on peer pressure and adolescence became something else, a pseudo-tragic passion play of inchoate drama. Eli's final act is melodrama, and Ben's performance at the prom contrived.
Joel Edgerton, Everett Blunck, Kayo Martin, Kenny Rasmussen, Lucas Adler, Caden Burris, Elliott Hefferman, Lennox Espy, Kolton Lee
Not quite fully developed but insightful take on social media, how it creates a false sense of relationship, corrupts the relationships, and twists people into imagined self-concept. Matthew Morning works at a clothing store frequented by celebrities. One day, his hero, Oliver, comes in. They quickly establish a friendly relationship-- Oliver blathering about authenticity and so on-- and Matthew is invited into the "club", Oliver's retinue of sycophants and hangers-on, and given to understand that he should make himself useful in some way. He cleans up and washes dishes. In one of the least credible aspects of "Lurker", he slides into making a documentary about Oliver. The trouble is the video we are shown that is taken by him is so ridiculously bad that we can't even believe it has a kind of rustic, "authentic" appeal. It's just ugly and jerky and incoherent in any sense. Matthew brings along a friend, Jamie, from the store who begins to insinuate his way into the entourage provoking Matthew's jealousy. When Matthew sabotages Jamie and is dumped (abandoned in London while the retinue flies back to LA), he unbelievably sets up some kind of assignation with a couple of under-age girls with Oliver and records it and then uses it to blackmail Oliver into accepting him back into his circle to let him finish his documentary. Big problem here: the idea that he could set up the girls this way is just not credible, and not even worked out very well. Secondly, we are asked to believe that Oliver wouldn't assume that Matthew would have a back-up copy of the video somewhere: he thinks it's exclusively on a hard-drive he sees in Matthew's possession, and assumes Matthew would actually keep it with him in Oliver's house. Thirdly, why wouldn't Oliver stand up to Matthew, claim that he thought the girls were 18, and weather the storm, rather than put up with his cringy insinuation back into the group? There is a quasi homosexual undertow here that isn't worked out very much either. Wonderfully filmed and generally well-acted and important for its astute take on social media and influencer culture.
Theodore Pellerin, Archie Madekwe, Sunny Suljic, Cam Hicks, Zack Fox, Daniel Zolghadri, Havana Rose Liu
What is going on here? Even if you know, you don't. A large group of teenagers all head out to Monty's, a delicatessen, for an important sort of mating ritual in which they are chosen or not. The chosen go on to some kind of meaningful life; the rest remain in town drinking the dredges of what life has to offer, hanging out, dead-end jobs, unattractive mates. That's the gist of it, but the film is so slow-paced and unreactive that it's hard to tell what is meant to be meant and what is not. At the heart of "Ham on Rye" is the suggestion that your destiny in life is the result of random, unaccountable happenstance. There is no obvious reason why Haley, for example, is not chosen, while Trish and Gwen are. The music is funky and interesting, the performances are good, and the cinematography is okay.
Haley Bodell, Audrey Boos, Gabriella Herrera, Adam Torres, Luke Darga, Blake Borders, Gregory Falatek
Gerry and Stella have been married a long time. A lone son lives somewhere else. Stella decides they must do a trip and so she buys tickets to Amsterdam and arranges a hotel. None of these or other details are ever carefully presented in "Midwinter Break". They are all just gestures, steps to the real object of the case: Stella's self-pity and dissatisfaction. Gerry might be dissatisfied too-- we don't know, because director Polly Findlay uses him exclusively as a prop for Stella's misery. Gerry has barely a personality and no conspicuous interests or opinions and he seems dismally incapable of standing up to Stella's hectoring and insults. As they travel around Amsterdam, he doesn't seem curious or appreciative of anything, really, and after touring the Anne Frank house and Stella tells him how bad she feels about not having prevented the holocaust a director worth half her salt would have had him bite back. Instead, he becomes abject, finally declaring just how marvelous and wondrous Stella has been for him and how much he needs her, for which she consents to let him hold her hand. Stella announces they should sell their flat and she will move to her own place. Why sell the flat? Presumably, Gerry can stay there. Because this movie is about set pieces, not any authentic experiences. "Midwinter Break" has the pace and aesthetic of something deep but it's really just a dreary self-indulgent tribute to the director's good taste in herself.
Lesley Manville, Ciaran Hinds, Julie Lamberton, Ed Sayer
Essentially a character study, "Marty Supreme" is more than two hours of an obnoxiously overconfident ping pong hustler named Marty Mauser. Marty is a hustler, like Duddy Kravitz, aiming for the big time, dreaming of beating the best players in the world if he can only raise the money to fly to London and Tokyo. He has a girlfriend, Rachel, who is married, but pregnant by Marty. He tries various schemes to get the money, trying to make a deal with an ink manufacturer, and with his wife, a famous actress (who decides to do Broadway with her husband's money), kidnapping a dog and holding it for ransom, doing half-time shows with the Harlem Globetrotters. He isn't without some ethics but his determination makes life dangerous for those close to him. Marty Mauser is a real person, but "Marty Supreme" doesn't pretend to stick close to the facts. (Spoiler alert: the real Marty lost that game in Japan.) But apparently the story about Bela Kletzki, a survivor of Auschwitz, and the honey, is true. Superbly acted and directed with a funky, aggressive musical background. One does wonder if the subject of the film is worthy of the performance.
Timothee Chalamet, Gwyneth Paltrow, Odessa A'zion, Larry Sloman, Mariann Tepedino, Luke Manley, Fran Drescher, Sandra Bernhard, Kevin O'Leary, Abel Ferrara, David Mamet, Tomoki Urabe
Moody, visually splendid, explicit take on bullfighting, mainly in the perspective of Peruvian matador Andres Roca Rey, who takes on three bulls in this romp, killing all three (one of them sloppily), and displaying his magnetism, focus, and vulnerability as the camera lavishes it's attention on him-- and on the bulls. We see him in the ring, on the side waiting, getting dressed, getting treated for injuries when a bull rams him hard. We see him and his banderilleros and picadors conversing inside a vehicle as they are transported to and from the ring. The conversations don't sound pimped for the film; they are kind of banal and anodyne at times, discussing whether it was a "good" bull or not, and what other matadors are doing. But the meat of this film is the bull, the dynamism between matador and victim, the gesticulating, the macho postures of the matador. It doesn't judge, but by making the barbaric explicit it probably does more to inform us than any other film on bullfighting I've ever seen.
Andrews Roca Rey, Roberto Dominguez, Francisco Manuel Duran, Francisco Gomez, Manuel Lara, Antonio Gutierrez
Documentary about Judit Polgar, a young Hungarian woman who eventually (after 11 tries) defeated Garry Kasparov, the current World Champion. Judit was raised by her father to be a chess master (along with her two sisters, Susan and Sofia), through intensive drilling and study, including monstrous file cabinets full of "problems" and puzzles. She became the youngest International Master (besting Bobby Fischer's record by two months) and went on to win many tournaments and to defeat many top male players. The documentary overplays a dramatic but trifling incident in which Garry Kasparov moved a knight, released it, then moved it back, breaking a cardinal rule, and was not caught by the judges. It almost certainly would not have altered the outcome of the game but it is played here as a token of injustice and oppression. Kasparov probably underestimated Judit and may not have played his best game (a possibility not elucidated by this film). Judit played Kasparov many times subsequent to that game and lost all of them until the penultimate match of the film. Kasparov graciously acknowledged her standing and even had her over to his vacation home for a time and trained with her. Judit Polgar is interesting, a compelling subject for a film, and her achievements are notable. For all that, there is still only a tiny handful of women ranked in the top 100 of the world, and most women only compete in women's only tournaments. And for all the attention paid to her upbringing, she seems pleasantly down-to-earth. She is now married and has taken up the role of coach to the Hungarian National men's team.
Judit Polgarf, Garry Kasparov, Sofia Polgar, Susan Polgar
Co-written by Nick Drake and Barbara Winton (daughter of Nicholas Winton). Bland telling of a compelling story: how Nicholas Winton, a British stock broker, helped bring 669 Jewish children from Prague to foster homes in the U. K. (Karel Reisz, a film director, and journalist Joe Schlesinger, were among the children). The film acknowledges what was a bit of a sore point earlier: it conspicuously credits the others involved, many of whom actually worked in Prague while Winton worked mostly from London. Artistically, "One Life" is obvious and predictable and plays up opposition though not too unduly (bureaucrats say it can't be done and then do it anyway). The Netherlands initially refused Jewish refugees but relented only when Winton assured them that they would pass through to Britain. Sweden was the only other country to accept them. Hopkins gives an unusually bland performance and the rest of cast doesn't really have much to except look earnest or worshipful. Winton has been called "England's Schindler" but doesn't really stand up to that kind of comparison. He was a decent human being who did the right thing. At that point in history, that makes him a saint.
Anthony Hopkins, Lena Olin, Helena Bonham Carter, Johnny Flynn, Matilda Thorpe, Tim Steend, Daniel Brown, Alex Sharp, Jiri Simek, Romola Garai, Michael Gould, Marthe Keller
Ali Aksu is a dirty old man living in Bremen, Germany. He visits bordellos and drinks and smokes and likes to know if his son, Nejat, has screwed anyone lately. But he's getting older and one day invites a local Turkish prostitute, Yeter Ozturk, to come live with him. She has a daughter , Ayten, living in Turkey that she has lost contact with. Yeter's daughter thinks she works in a shoe store; Yeter doesn't know that her daughter is an activist and is in trouble with the authorities and has to flee, to Bremen. A series of coincidences and unlikely situations unfold, unconvincingly at times. And there is some unearned grace at work. The only remotely likeable character, in my book, is Nejat, though he is insular and restrained. Ayten has a relationship with a German girl, Lotte, whose mother doesn't approve (until she does); both of them are obstreperous and annoyingly short-fused. Lotte invites Ayten, who has nowhere to sleep, into her home, and Ayten proceeds to lecture Lotte's mom about human rights seemingly oblivious to the fact that she is a guest. It could happen that way, but it struck as many things in the film did as a schematic element, as when Lotte buys a hungry Ayten dinner at a restaurant and she orders a massive amount of food: the director wants us to know that she is very hungry. When Lotte is looking for her passport, she tosses everything in her bedroom to the floor: we are being told that she is desperate to find the passport and doesn't care what her mother thinks. Lotte's mother repents by moving to Turkey to live in an apartment owned by Nejat. A little too tidy, too cute. The viewer is advised to check out Nuri Ceylan instead, whose films are genuinely wonderful.
Baki Davrak, Gursoy Gemec, Tuncel Kurtiz, Nursel Kose, Nurgul Yesilcay, Erkan Can, Patrycia Ziolkowska, Hanna Schygulla
Most films on the subject of substance addiction start with the descent into addiction, the increasing desperation and disregard for work, family, friends, and then the bottoming out and the pathetic, crushing weight of isolation and rejection. And then, of course, the redemption. "Oslo.31.August" starts out with the recovery: Anders is released from a treatment program and heads back to Oslo to reconnect with friends and former lovers and try to get some kind of direction to his life. He is openly pessimistic, telling his friend Thomas that he is considering suicide. The subject is brought up repeatedly, by Anders, and by strangers he overhears at a cafe. Anders proceeds to meet with other friends, while repeatedly trying to contact a former lover, Iselin, whom Thomas tells him is still in love with him. She doesn't return his calls. His sister refuses to meet with him-- we get the clear idea that he has abused their relationship in the past-- and he learns that his parents had to sell their house presumably as a result of Anders' actions. He is filled with guilt and self-remonstration and self-reproach while doing nothing to change his life. When he applies for a job and has to admit he was in a drug rehabilitation program for that long blank period of his CV, he makes no effort to convince the interviewer that he has any prospect of staying clean. He meets a lovely girl at a rave but resists her invitation to join him while skinny dipping because of crippling memories of his own suicide attempt a la Virginia Woolf. A harsh, unfussy film, honest, and authentic; Danielsen Lie Anders is remarkably convincing as Anders.
Anders Danielsen Lee, Hans Olav Brenner, Ingrid Olava, Malin Crepin, Aksel Thanke, Oystein Roger, Kjaersti Odden Skjeldal, Emil Lund, Renate Reinsve
Aurora is a "picker" at a "fulfillment" centre, a Portuguese immigrant, gathering items into a bin for forwarding to customers. She walks a financial tightrope and when her indispensable cellphone breaks one day requiring an expensive repair, she is right pinched, unable to even afford enough food for herself (she poignantly-- against her nature-- steals a bag of chips). She lives in a boarding house along with others including Kris, a likeable Pole, who is friendly and generous and whose shoulder she delicately leans on one night in a bar. She has applied for another job but she is so disoriented by her predicament that she can't muster a good self to present to a kindly interviewer. In fact, all of the characters in "On Falling" are remarkably civil and reasonable and often kind. They're all trying to get by and to be fair each other. A Portuguese friend reminds her, kindly, to pay her share of the petrol, and Kris pays her electricity bill at one point, though he accepts that she will pay him back. We see how minimum wage jobs for faceless corporations run by hacks grinds people into submission and resignation, limits their possibilities (when a potential employer asks Aurora what she does in spare time, she has no answer), and shutters their horizons. We see how these individuals cling to the pseudo-relationships on their smartphones, constantly hiding behind those screens while sitting near or beside others who also long for real human interaction, for a touch, an embrace. A beautiful, remarkable film that everyone will see, but nobody I know will see because it doesn't even have a villain (other than the corporation, the system).
Joana Santos, Ines Vaz, Piotr Sikora, Neil Leiper, Jake McGarry, Itxaso Morena, Deborah Arnott, Karyna Khymchuk
Thoughtful, funny, irreverent documentary about efforts to fortify schools and students against potential mass killers. Clips of salesmen trying to foist their bulletproof tables and shields on credulous school boards, training sessions for teachers on using hand guns, simulations with students of mass casualty events, all tinged with skepticism and some tragic amusement as participants gloss over the more obvious solution of banning or restricting access to guns. Perhaps unsatisfying in some respects, but that's partly because the political climate is so toxic that no actual government action seems imaginable. Some very compelling interviews with students, particular a boy-girl combo reflecting on the fact that they have to be wary of being shot at their school.
Quinn Davis, Kannon Davis, Rachel Rachel, Mike Smith, Summer Summer, Ron Havniear, Bret Champion
Marcelo (or Armando) drives to Recife in his yellow Volkswagen Beetle where he visits his father-in-law and mother-in-law and son, Fernando. His wife, Fatima, has died, and his father-in-law, Carlos, expresses his concern that Armando stays safe for the sake of his son. He also connects with members of an organization opposed to the government who offer to help him acquire a fake passport and leave Brazil. He has become the target of a wealthy industrialist, Henrique Ghirotti, who attacked his department at University so he could seize their work for his own family-owned corporation. At a meeting with Ghirotti, Armando attacked Ghirotti's son, and his wife insulted Ghirotti and his son. We are never told what exactly happened to Fatima but it is clearly implied that she was murdered by the government or by henchmen employed by Ghirotti, who has now hired hitmen to pursue Armando, clearly with complicit help from the government. There is also a subplot about a human leg found in the stomach of a tiger shark near the coast, which, in a magical sequence, escapes the mortuary and begins attacking gay prostitutes and others in a city park. For a story about the Brazilian dictatorship and its victims, surprisingly undogmatic. Carlos thinks Armando cheated on Fatima (it appears likely), and Armando seems willful and petulant at times. The cinematography is a bit uneven, rustic at times, but the music is funky and lively, and the acting is superb, especially in ensemble bits like when the police set up an identity bureau to look like a police station so the mother of a maid can be interviewed about the tragic death of a child in the maid's care. And it's not clear who is working for who: the two hit men hire a shooter but the corrupt, complicit police challenge and then he challenges one of the men who hired him. This simply a terrific film, complex, rich, and compelling.
Wagner Moura, Tania Maria, Roberio Diogenes, Thomas Aquino, Udo Kier, Carlos Francisco, Gregorio Graziosi, Gabriel Leone, Enzo Nunes, Luciano Chirolli
Does Zhao's co-writing credit indicate improvisation by the actors? I suspect many scenes were, in fact, improvised. That, or just badly written. Perhaps both. Hugely disappointing imaginary story about Agnes, Shakespeare's wife (who is called "Anne" in most biographies) and-- surprise-- NOT how SHE actually wrote the plays, but how she was magically connected to mother earth and had magical perceptions of Will and their children. Zhao is projecting some modern sensibilities upon a historical figure we know very little about. One thing we should know is that the death of children in the 1580's or 90's was not the shocking trauma shown here. Awful and tragic, yes, but "Hamnet" conveys nothing of the sense parents would have had that the death of a child would be a fact of life (so much so that none of Shakespeare's children's children survived childhood-- not one!) Nor would one expect Agnes to be appalled that Will was not in Stratford at the moment Judith became ill or Hamnet died. And nor would one expect to see the play, "Hamlet", as a representation of Will's suppressed grief, especially when it's not particularly sorrowful about any of the multiple deaths in the play (Hamlet mocks Polonius after accidentally killing him, provokes Ophelia's suicide, has two messengers casually murdered, and then takes out Laertes and Claudius). Perhaps "Lear" would have worked better, given his words about the death of his daughter, Cordelia. "Hamnet" is directed by a woman and written by a woman and one can't resist alluding to the criticism that too many women's movies and books are about the women, about their suffering, their feelings, their desires. We are shown Agnes emoting time and time again, spectacularly so. Would you really make a movie about Shakespeare that gives such prominent expression to the idea that maybe he should have been home more often? That he should have spent more time with his family than writing "Hamlet" or "Macbeth" or "Othello" or "Midsummer Night's Dream" or "Tempest" or whatever? Jessie Buckley's lavish rendering of Agnes' sensitivities and anguish actually bores at times, and risks suggesting a kind of masochistic narcissism: watch me suffer! Look at my beautifully distorted face. Listen to my screeching horror at death. Zhao indulges her at the expensive of narrative coherence, which was already depleted by the Buckley's age (she was 34 at the time of filming; Mescal was 28. They should have been 26 and 18). She is overwrought, infatuated with her own despair. Why is this story even about Shakespeare? Why is he in the film? It's not about anything to do with the writer of plays-- it's about feelings. As for Will, Paul Mescal doesn't convey much of anything resembling anything you might imagine in the character of the author of Shakespeare's plays. He's an ingenue, an imitation. When he looks at Agnes from backstage at the performance at the Globe, he looks like an adolescent watching a hot girl at the prom knowing he'll never dance with her. The resolution is silly: the play's conclusion is borderline comical, bodies falling everywhere, people announcing that they are poisoned and then announcing that they are dead, and asking a bit player to make sure it's all gloriously memorialized when you really just want them to drag the bodies off the stage and bring out a comedy. I feel quite sure that Zhao chose "Hamlet" because, aside from the name, it's an iconic play, a quick, cheap patina on what is really a soap opera. Watch "Topsy Turvy" to see what a real master director can do with the subject of theatrical productions in the past. I feel sure that Buckley will win the Oscar for Best Actress not because she was the best actress (her performance was extremely narrow in scope) but because it's the type of wanton performance that fools you into thinking commitment is art. After checking the trivia: indeed, there was a lot of improvisation, including the last scene of the hands reaching towards the "dying" Hamlet.
Jessie Buckley, Paul Mescal, Emily Watson, David Wilmot, Elliot Baxter
Teddy's mom is critically ill from some kind of contamination caused by, he thinks, the Auxolith Corporation, and he holds it's CEO, Michelle, responsible. He also keeps bees, and he blames Auxolith for the decrease in bee population. So he and his friend Don kidnap Michelle, imprison her in the basement of their remote house (on the edge of a small town), and try to persuade, through interrogation and torture, to reveal the secrets of the alien invasion she is obviously a leader of. Teddy is an amateur astronomer and associates her with some kind of Andromedan race of super aliens. They cut her hair because that's how she communicates with the mothership (for which Emma Stone actually agreed to have her head shaved on camera) and cover her with white antihistamine cream.. Teddy is a total conspiracy theorist, completely immune to reason or facts. Don is compliant, addled assistant. A local sheriff, Ricky, comes to house and apologizes for, apparently, having molested Teddy when he babysat him years before. While there, he doesn't hear Michelle and Don conversing in the basement-- a bit of a weird stretch here. There's some fun in watching Michelle joust intellectually with Teddy, eventually convincing him that maybe she is an alien and can transport him to the mothership to meet the "emperor" and demand a cure for whatever he thinks Auxolith is doing. It's all bizarre in a the way most Lanthimos films are bizarre, with, perhaps, a more conventional narrative framework to hang it all on. The music is unusual: heavily bombastic, like a hyper 50's melodrama. And it's fun when Michelle returns to the corporation headquarters with Teddy in tow, surprising her staff who correctly assumed she had been kidnapped. The committed performances and the ending almost redeems the movie from mere weirdness. Languid shots, music, contemplative rumination. It kind of worked. It's original. It's fresh. It has overtones of a substantive consideration of ecology and paranoia. It reverberates with the MAGA movement and manipulative corporate heartlessness (Michelle tells her employees they can leave work at 5:30 if they really want to unless they don't want to but they can, maybe).
Emma Stone, Jesse Plemons, Aidan Delbis, J. Carmen Galindez Barrera, Marc T. Lewis, Alicia Silverstone
Documentary on the Holocaust survivor, writer, and speaker Elie Wiesel, who perhaps did more than anyone to sear the memory of the Holocaust into the collective soul of western culture. Traces his pre-war life in Rumania, the small village of mostly Jews he grew up, his transit to Auschwitz, his career as a reporter for the United Nations and public speaker. Wiesel eventually married and had children, Elijah and Elisha, even though he at one time vowed he would never bring children into this world. Interesting confrontation with Ronald Reagan over his decision to visit the Bitburg Cemetery where 50 SS men had been buried-- a really tone-deaf decision, in retrospect. Wiesel felt he had almost talked Reagan out of it until his aides and Chancellor Kohl were able to persuade him to go through with it. In 1986, Wiesel won the Nobel Peace Prize. This documentary does the job without either brilliance or contrivance, except for the animation sequences at the beginning which are compelling and effective. Be it noted, that there is some controversy about Wiesel's role in creating a "holocaust industry", and his Zionism which is played down in this film. He makes one modest allusion to the rights of Palestinians, but Netanyahu has made such allusions as well: they don't mean a thing unless you commit to a Palestinian state.
Elie Wiesel, Elijah Wiesel, Ronald Reagan, Marion Wiesel
Are all films and books by women about themselves? No, but "If I Had Legs I'd Kick You" is the pinnacle of that trend. Linda has a daughter (whom we almost never see) with an eating disorder of some kind. Her husband, a ship's captain, is away for 8 weeks. Her apartment suddenly has a hole in the ceiling and water flooding in. Her daughter's doctor is threatening to drop her from her program and is quite coldly hostile to Linda. Linda's husband yells at her over the phone complaining that she's not handling things well. Her patients seem to be narcissistic losers. Her own psychiatrist is chillingly indifferent to her issues. It's two hours of one misfortune after another, many of which are authored by Linda herself. What is the point of this exercise other than to bludgeon the audience into witnessing Linda's contortions? She is clearly often at fault. There is no real villain-- well, everyone's a villain. She is incapable of managing her life and I assume we are supposed to appalled at the fact that nobody, especially her psychiatrist, actually offers help. Rose Byrne is excellent in the role, but it's hard not to eventually want to scream at her: just say no. Just find a different psychiatrist. Just calmly pull over and take the hamster away from the child. Just tell James to fuck off. There are direct allusions to a nanny who murdered the children in her care and Andrea Yates who drowned her five children in a bathtub. What is being suggested? That there are understandable reasons why a mother might devoutly wish to be rid of her child? Or that the pressures of motherhood are so great that it is understandable that a mother would? It might have worked better if the people around Linda were not caricatured. Her psychiatrist seems too easily rattled. Her husband is ridiculously mean. James is creepy and gets drugs for her. Dr. Spring regards her with contempt. The parking attendant threatens to call the police on her. The hotel clerk is petulant. Her patient, Caroline, is sinisterly dependent and manipulative. But we don't see them as a statement on humanity so much as obstacles to Linda's personal well-being. It doesn't work very well, especially when Linda screams at Dr. Spring that, after all, it is her fault. She is resisting the bland reassurance because it doesn't solve anything for her. Carolyn Kelly at RogerEbert.com asserts that this is all about the way men don't listen, though, actually, the women in the film are at least as cruel and indifferent as the men. I suppose Kelly would say that too is the fault of the men.
Rose Byrne, Conan O'Brien, Danielle Macdonald, Delaney Quinn, Mary Bronstein, Rocky ASAP, Christian Slater, Ivy Wolkd, Mark Stolzenberg
This is a vanity project by one of the subjects, Paul Fronsczak (producer) who grew up in a loving home in Chicago and who discovered, when he was about 10, that he had been kidnapped in 1964 out of the maternity ward when he was a newborn and then found again by the FBI 15 months later in New York. Actually, the FBI didn't find him: he was abandoned in front of a cafe, given to a foster family, and then connected to the Chicago disappearance. It is not difficult to see that he might not actually be the child of his parents, the sibling of his brother David. So, after a restless adult life (no contact with his parents sometimes for over a year), a marriage, and a daughter of his own, Paul sets out to do a DNA test. He is not his parents' child. So what happened to the real Paul Fronczak, and who is he, really? Turns out he is Jack Rosenthal and he has a twin sister. It's not really a creditable documentary, and there's not a lot of rigor to the research and documentation here. For example, a woman named Susan Wohlert claims to have babysat the twins but the details sound suspiciously like they may have been absorbed from media coverage of the story. But it is a fascinating story and appears to be relatively accurate. Conspicuously absent (after the DNA tests) are his siblings and father. Why, one must wonder. And where is his twin sister Jill?
Tobe Dresner, Janet Eckert, David Fronczak, Paul Fronczak, Michelle Fronczak, Alan Fisch, George Knapp, CeCe Moore, Lenny Rocco, Susan Wohlert
Cheesy, soapish, contrived melodrama about a child disappearance. Marissa and Peter Irvine are rich and privileged and selfish and narcissistic-- though I think we are supposed to think that Marissa is a bit put-upon by the pressures of being both a fantastically brilliant fund manager and a great mom, while husband, Peter, is neglectful and selfish and whatever it is women hate about men nowadays. Their son, Milo, disappears on a play-date one day and a very shallow and under-developed procedural begins to uncover incredibly unlikely-- though sometimes clever-- connections between the couple and a psychotic (or is she?) nanny named Becky who seems to have taken the child. Detective Alcaras (and his token side-kick), who don't seem to have the slightest resonance with actual detective work, slowly unpeel this rotten onion (while exhibiting some corruption of his own). The Guardian inexplicably praised this series because it said something important about how women today are pressured into "doing it all" and how they suffer so much men when patronize them while basically seeking their own interests. All of this is seriously-- I mean, seriously-- undermined by the family's wealth and the fact that both Marissa and Jenny Kaminiski-- the supposed victims-- have full-time nanny's to do most of the childcare for them. Did the writers even consider this problem? Add to that, conspicuously bad acting, dreary music (really, just elevator muzak), and predictable character tropes (the weirdly youthful nanny, the disabled brother who resents dependence, the sister unfairly blamed for the disabled brother's disability, the horrible gratification- centric parenting), and you have one of the worst mini-series of the last decade.
Michael Pena, Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning, Jake Lacy, Daniel Monks, Abby Elliot, Thomas Cocquerel, Tayden Jax Ryan, Duke McCloud, Sophia Lillis, Melanie Vallejo, Kartiah Vergara
A fine film from Linklater about the esteemed (if you like musicals) song-writer (lyricist) Lorenz Hart, who collaborated with composer Richard Rodgers on a number of successful Broadway musicals including "The Boys From Syracuse", "Pal Joey", and "On Your Toes". But this time, it's Rodgers and Hammerstein and Hart is in the audience at the premiere of their celebrated new musical "Oklahoma", famous for it's unusual integration of musical and dramatic sequences. Hart despises Hammerstein's lyrics as shallow and trivial and corny (literally). But we soon learn why Rodgers is now working with a new lyricist: Hart is an alcoholic. He's also gay, and very short (less than five feet), and very, very annoying. The first half hour here is just him blathering away. But the blather is evocative of a thin-skinned man with real talent and the ego to go with it and a painful awareness of his displacement in the world, as a homosexual, as a drunk, as a writer who has lost his currency. Along comes Rodgers fresh from his debut, and Hammerstein, and they are unexpectedly civil, generous to Hart, and kind. But Rodgers conveys the tone of a man long frustrated with Hart's cynicism and unreliability (not showing up on time for work sessions). Hart is also dismissive of the "Oklahoma" as a product of nostalgia that provides cheap comfort. Hart: what's wrong with comfort? It's wartime and people want escape. Also arriving is Elizabeth, a 20-year-old student from Yale who clearly sees Hart as a stepping stone to greater things, but whom Hart mistakenly believes could love him. All of these characters are believably complex, nuanced, and richly realized. You get why they don't just dismiss Hart (Rodgers even invites him to a cast party at his apartment). There's long history and friendship at stake. But Hart, who has promised to clean himself up, keeps drinking, and we already know how that ends.
Ethan Hawke, Andrew Scott, Bobby Cannavale, Margaret Qualley, Patrick Kennedy, Jonah Lees, Simon Delaney, Cillian Sullivan
Beautiful, elegiac, meditative, monstrous, and incomprehensible, Tarr's magnus opus is a very long, black and white, slow-moving dive into something that feels profound and probably is profound but is very elusive. Is it a profound Bergmanesque exploration of mortality and sin? Or a cinematic "Finnegan's Wake" or "Ulysses" (James Joyce)? The bones of it are this: an agricultural collective in a dreary, muddy, decaying town is falling apart, with some members resorting to swindling and theft, and others drinking themselves into oblivion, and, in one extraordinary scene consisting of one ten-minute take, dancing a bizarre, desperate tango to an accordion. Their lives are all mean, dirty, and rude. Spoiler alert (you'll never see this film so why not?): a young girl buries her money only to have her brother steal it; then she finds a cat and murders it and then herself. But look-- it's black and white and beautifully composed! I cannot really go along with the incredible high regard this film has in some quarters. I suspect it may be, as I said, like "Ulysses" or "Being and Time" (Heidegger): an illusion of profundity created by obscurity. Is there something hiding behind the obscurity? I don't think so. But it is at times beautiful to watch, and to think about yourself, and think about what "watching" is, and space and time, and cats and little girls.
Mihaly Vig, Putyi Horvath, Laszlo feLugossy, Eva Almassy Albert, Janos Derzsi, Iren Szajki, Alfred Jarai, Miklos B. Szekely, Erzsebet Gaal
And written by Rachel Reid. The great mystery is why is this shamelessly cheesy gay soap-opera so highly praised among the internet audience and reviewers? Based on the book "Game Changers", romance published by Carina (formerly Harlequin), by Rachel Reid who openly asserts that she was ashamed of hockey culture because it was so homophobic. This gives her "permission" to cast the "heroes", Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov, improbably in 2025, as persecuted victims who must hide their love or face oppression. The problem for the novel is that in 2025 there really isn't all that much oppression available, so the TV series took the liberty of focusing on Rozanov's Russian citizenship, where he does risk arrest or imprisonment back home for his sexual orientation. The plot consists mostly of long stretches of Shane and Ilya smooching and grappling (thank you to the "intimacy coordinator, Chala Hunter), and expressing their desire for each other in increasingly devout terms until, doggonit, they are ready to admit they really love each other. In one telling scene (about where this production is coming from), Ilya performs oral sex on Shane while he is on the phone with a teammate, Hayden. Hilarious, if you thought "Three's Company" was fresh. Shane's parents are enlightened and immediately accept them. End of story. Is there anything here that makes it compelling or worthy of six episodes? Not the professional sports milieu which is merely touched on (they don't even use the real names of the League, or any specific NHL team), or the personalities of Shane and Ilya, who have none, or their interactions with other players, reporters, agents, lawyers, sports personalities: there is nothing to speak of there except the most desultory transactions. There is not a single scene that comes even close to the scene of Billy Beane offering a contract to Scott Hatteberg in "Moneyball" in terms of simple cinematic interest. Note: at the audition , Shane Hollander was so impressed with Storrie that he told Tierney that "Connor felt like he was going to pin me down and fuck me", and so Storrie got the part. So how much of the esteem for this program is overwhelming self- infatuation of liberals and progressives who see being fan of this show as a badge of enlightened virtue? A lot, I think.
Hudson Williams, Connor Storrie, Sophie Nelisse, Franco Lo Presti, Francois Arnaud, Ksenia Daniela Kharlamova, Slavic Rogozine, Christina Chang, Dylan Walsh
Well-acted and written drama about the election and short presidency of James Garfield, who was assassinated in 1881 by a deranged egoist named Charles Guiteau. Parallel stories, of Garfield unwillingly thrust into the presidency after the Republican convention couldn't settle between the two most popular candidates, and the peripatetic adventures of Guiteau, an unstable man of absurd delusions about his capabilities and achievements, who imposed himself upon Garfield and other political figures only to be rebuffed and shuns and eventually becomes convinced that God wants him to assassinate Garfield so vice-president Chester Arthur can become president. Relatively faithful to history (except for Crete Garfield visiting Guiteau in prison to lecture him) and entertaining because the actually history is quite interesting. I never knew that Garfield (and, actually, Arthur) had set out to clean up corruption in government service. He was also enlightened on racial issues. Amazingly, a black doctor was in the vicinity when Garfield was shot (true!) and was the first to treat him. I am doubtful of the accuracy of his interaction with other people attending to him (just a bit tidy). Chester Arthur later appointed him head of a hospital associated with Howard University.
Matthew Macfadyen, Michael Shannon, Betty Gilpin, Shea Whigham, Bradley Whitford, Nick Offerman, Zeljko Ivanek, Paula Malcomson, Shaun Parkes, Archie Fisher, Laura Marcus
Jane Austen lived from 1775 to 1817 (she died at 41) and never knew fame and fortune though her first six novels were well-received. Unfortunately, we know little of her personal life because her sister, Cassandra, burned most of her letters. The family had a steady but unreliable income though descended from wealth. George, her father, was given over to a nursemaid for about 18 months after birth. Eliza was Jane's French cousin (and later sister-in-law, married to Henry-- her first husband had been guillotined!) and in this series it is she who receives the bulk of Janes forthright, candid, and critical letters. Jane was quite open about her views of family members and neighbors (which is probably why Cassandra disposed of the letters). We follow Cassandra as she helps the family move out of the parsonage after being displaced and desperately searches for Jane's letters to Eliza. Cassandra and Jane's sister-in-law, Mary Austen (married to James) also wants those letters and keeps pestering Cassandra about it. Cassandra is a busybody, trying to arrange marriages and domiciles for the displaced family members and servants, and, in this telling, filled with over-flowing self-infatuation. We know Jane and Cassandra were close (Jane was also close to Henry), but the sanctification of their relationship becomes a bit suffocating at times. They spend a lot of time in "Godmersham Park in Kent, the home brother Edward, between 1798 and 1813. Austen accepted a marriage proposal from Harris Bigg-Wither, an unattractive man she had known since child-hood, but regretted it the next day and rescinded it. Janes father died in 1805 leaving the family in financial straits. She and Cassandra and their mother traveled and stayed with various family and friends for a time. In 1809, Janes' brother Edward offered the family the cottage in Chawton village where they lived quietly until Jane's death in 1917. She was moved to Winchester as her illness progressed and died there. "Miss Austen" is lush and beautifully filmed, though the background music is lushly banal. Cassandra is unintentionally (I think) portrayed unflatteringly. She lies. She declines an offer of marriage because she pledged eternal troth to her first husband but he died in 1797 of yellow fever in the Caribbean (leaving Cassandra £1,000). There is no objective evidence for the second proposal that Cassandra declined.
Keeley Hawes, Patsy Ferran, Alred Enoch, Liv Hill, Jessica Hynes, Max Irons, Synnove Karlsen, Rose Leslie, Rose Leslie, Phyllis Logan, Mirren Mack, Carys Bowkett, Madeleine Walker, Felix Scott
Co-directed by Agnes Hranitzky. Not for everyone. A beautiful, transcendent film of exquisite images and sequences (39 long tracking shots- extraordinary durations). Black and white with quality that almost convinces you that all film should return to black and white. We see the small town through the eyes of Janos Valuska, a young man who delivers newspapers and assists his distinguished musician uncle, Gyorgy Eszter. A circus comes to town with a large whale in a trailer and a "prince" whom we never see. This seems to set off some kind of reverberations in the town that destabilize the community and lead to unease, anger, and violence. In one riveting sequence, a large-- very large-- group of men march through town carrying clubs, facing the camera which dollies back continuously. They are silent, grim-faced, rhythmic in their motions, a unfeeling force of humanity unstrung, until they reach the hospital where they unleash their fury at the patients, the furnishings, the building itself. But the most curious element is the giant whale brought to town in a long flimsy trailer. Both Janos and Gyorgy examine it closely, in wonder, and stare at its unseeing eye. Is it a fake? We don't really know if we are supposed to believe it is real (it certainly looks fake), but it clearly represents the wonder of nature or god, the possibility of mysterious things that stretch our comprehension (or break it). Very beautiful film.
Lars Rudolph, Peter Fitz, Hanna Schygulla, Janos Derzsi, Alfred Jarai, Mihaly Kormos, Ferenc Kallai
James Mooney is a failure. We are not supplied much detail about why or how, as we are not given much detail about anything background in "Mastermind", but he has clearly earned ambivalence from those close to him, including his sons. He decides to steal four paintings from a local museum. We are given to understand that they are very valuable though they don't look it. He hires a couple of crooks to help him out-- first mistake. One of them cops out and is replaced by someone even less reliable than the first two. Things go askew and he is on the run. Here we get better detail, hitch-hiking, catching a bus, staying at a friend's whose wife does not welcome him, moving to another friend's. These sequences have the feel of real life to them, especially the sense of being adrift and alone. And then a fizzle of an ending, which, at least, avoidance contrivance or predictability or predictable unpredictability. Reichardt's films are always welcome if only in relief from the endless gratification machinery of Hollywood. She is fresh and different and odd and you get the sense that she's looking for something to say about something about life and always gets at least part way there. The music, soundtrack, is mostly original progressive jazz. Didn't win my enthusiasm any more than it did when my son was in a progressive jazz band years ago.
Josh O'Connor, Sterling Thompson, Alana Haim, Jasper Thompson, Bill Camp, Hope Davis, Eli Gelb, Cole Doman, Javion Allen, Reighan Bean, Katie Hubbard
Based on the play by J. T. Rogers (who wrote the screenplay), covers the secret negotiations in Oslo between the Palestinian Minister of Finance and two professors from the University of Haifa which laid the groundwork for the Oslo Accords which, in view of current events, produced nothing of note except brief illusions about the parties willingness to commit to a real peace plan. It did set the path for Israel to leave Gaza allowing the Palestinian Authority to take over, which led to Hamas taking over, and we all know how that ended. That said, I don't trust the movie. It clearly favors a rather self- serving view of the roles of Mona Juul and Terje Rod-Larsen even suggesting that Juul "saved the day" at a critical point in the negotiations. The actors portraying the Palestinian and Israeli delegates do well, and the trajectory, from complete refusal to reluctant agreement is well-handled. So it's an interesting film from the historical perspective. Dramatically, it's all surfaces, predictable, and schematic. There's no weight of history or emotion to the characters, no sense that anyone has any ideas or attitudes in reserve. The Norwegian government did an investigation into the whole process in 2001 and concluded that Norway's "facilitators" generally acted as if only Israel's "red lines" mattered and the process could never have resulted in a sustainable peace. Unsurprisingly, the Accords were never widely accepted by the Palestinians, and Hamas successfully undermined them which resulted in Netanyahu of Likud winning the next election in Israel which stopped the process completely.
Andrew Scott, Ruth Wilson, Jeff Wilbusch, Karel Dobry, Itzik Cohen, Salim Daw, Doval'e Glickman, Sasson Gabay
Charming, light-hearted, and very funny depiction of Jean-Luc Godard's creation of "Breathless", focused on his refusal to follow any of the conventions of traditional film development. No plot, no dialogue, no second, third, or fourth takes. Just Godard's "inspirations" as he tries to think of how his protagonist, playing a real-life criminal, might act and what he might say. Jean Seberg comes along and is baffled but cooperative (and can't wait for it to end) while Jean Paul Belmondo is having fun and his producer is having fits. "Breathless" is not really a great film-- it's clumsy and awkward and stiff-- but it did have a shocking impact on the world of independent film: you could make a film with nothing, no money, no script, no sets. And the film could be about something important even if it is nothing more than the film-maker's consciousness of himself making a film. "Nouvelle Vague" is fun, well-acted and written, beautifully shot in black and white, and cheerfully insouciant. It's also a lot of fun to encounter other film-makers like Truffaut and Rohmer and Bresson as they interact with Godard (and his Cahiers du Cinema cohorts) and who went on to fame themselves as innovative, serious auteurs.
Guillaume Marbeck, Zoey Deutch, Aubry Dullin, Adrien Rouyard, Antoine Besson, Jodie Ruth-Forest, Bruno Dreyfurst, Benjamin Clery, Matthieu Penchinat, Pauline Belle
Hello. Based on book by Richard Flanagan whose father, apparently, was held in a Japanese POW camp. Early in this series, Dorrigo Evans, as an older doctor, is being interviewed by a reporter. After he describes some of the brutal treatment he received as a POW, the reporter says something to the effect of "wasn't our bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki also inhumane and brutal?" He is outraged and makes it clear that he thinks the reporter is dimwitted for not fully apprehending the depths of his sufferings and the monumental importance of his experience. I doubt most reporters would put it the way she did. A good reporter might ask how, given his experiences, he feels about the atomic bombs used on Japan. But the makers of this series want the reporter to be a prop for the Dorrigo's virtue and heightened consciousness. The scene feels fake, self-serving, and contrived, as does Dorrigo's meetings with the hospital panel supposedly considering taking away his license after he, having discovered additional cancers, proceeded to surgically remove them without specific consent, saving the life of the patient. For dramatic purposes, the patient should have died. The survival of the patient makes the hearing ridiculous. But that's what "Narrow Road..." is really about, that sophomoric presentation of long-suffering male ego (he drinks too, and cheats on his wife). When his wife, telling him she wants a divorce, tells him he is the loneliest man she ever knew, we are meant to take that as a tribute to his roguish individualism and integrity. His suffering is elevated even further by his passionate affair with Amy though we never really see what it is that attracts them to each other in the first place, other than those long meaningful looks that substitute for intelligible conversation. Yet "Narrow Road" was high praised even by The Guardian. I think they liked the grit, and the fact that the actors lost a lot of weight to look convincing in the prison camp. "King Rat" was probably better on the same subject except that at the time it was made they didn't really any means of making the men convincingly thin.
Heather Mitchell, Heather Mitchell, Jacob Elordi, Heather Mitchell, Simon Baker, Heather Mitchell, Paul Gleeson, Olivia DeJonge, Thomas Weatherall, Masa Yamaguchi, Caelan McCarthy
Jeremy Pastor returns to his home town of Saint-Michel to attend the funeral of his late boss. His late boss's wife, Martine, loves him, but her son, Vincent, thinks Jeremy is trying to seduce her and despises him. The local priest cast a knowing eye on events, though we don't know, at first, what he sees. Jeremy hits on Walter who is shocked and repulsed. This is a stew of mixed motives and iniquities and simmering conflicts that plays out into a disappearance and investigation by the police (Columbo style, asking questions, wondering about contradictions and omissions). Everyone seems to have a corrupt hidden desire, including the priest, who leverages his position into a carnal opportunity. What does Jeremy want? Sometimes, simple gratification. He is between jobs and considering taking over for the baker, though Vincent opposes him. Martine walks in on him bathing. Walter reconsiders rejection. Vincent has the clearest purpose. There is a shocking compromise of principles and morals that is convincing because we are shown how everyone is locked into their own existential motives and it is Jeremy who causes them to be revealed. Well-acted, well-written, well-filmed.
Felix Kysyl, Catherine Frot, Jean-Baptiste Durand, Serge Richard, Jacques Develay, David Ayala, Tatiana Spivakova, Sebastien Faglain, Salome Lopes
It's a horror film, and not much more. A good one: well acted and edited, and well-written. In a small New England town, an entire class of Grade 3 students-- except for one boy-- disappears over night. Cameras show that they all left their houses at exactly 2:17. They cannot be found anywhere, even with all the cameras-- which doesn't entirely make sense (the cameras should have shown more than we are given in the film). The teacher, Justine, comes under suspicion, and she is attacked verbally, and someone paints "witch" on her car. Other mysterious things happen. Alex, the lone remaining student of the class, has a secret that Justine tries to extract but fails. She convinces the principal to call in Alex's parents but his weird Aunt Gladys shows up instead trying hard to evade further investigation. A drug addict uncovers vital clues and wrangles assistance from the police but things get very weird. The film is good at dread, and because it is reasonably original and fresh, suspenseful where similar films are not. Above average-- a superior thriller but still just a thriller will little lasting impression.
Julia Garner, Josh Brolin, Alden Eherenreich, Gary Christopher, Jason Turner, Scarlett Sher, Benedict Wong, Thomas Whitmer, Amy Madigan, June Diane Raphael
Powerful, searing story of a broken relationship between a father, Gustav Borg, a film director, and his actress daughter, Nora. Nora has issues: she is seized with paralyzing anxiety before the opening of a theatrical performance-- and she blames it mostly on her father, who abandoned the family when she was very young. Her sister, Agnes, is more forgiving, and urges her to accept her father's offer of a role in a new film about his mother (Nora's grandmother). Agnes researches details about their grandmother and reads Gustav's script. Gustav also wants Agnes' son to be in the film. "Sentimental Value" is inventive, beautifully filmed, surprising, and often raw and authentic. Scenes of stage and film sometimes blend fearlessly with the real drama. There is a resolution, but it's not cheap and not contrived. And there is Rachel Kemp, a Hollywood star, whom Gustav does persuade to be in his film though she becomes ambivalent about the role, even after dyeing her hair and rehearsing the part extensively. The family home, handed down from Gustav's grandmother, becomes a central character in the story as well, and the locus of much of the family drama, the parental conflicts, the children listening in through the stove-pipes. There is a startling scene from an early Borg film, involving Nazis chasing two children, one of whom is played convincingly by Agnes. Above all, there are the intense, incredibly expressive faces of Gustav and Nora, and Agnes, and Rachel. A beautiful, moving film about family, and art, and individuality. One of the best films of the year.
Renate Reinsve, Stellan Skarsgard, Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas, Elle Fanning, Anders Danielsen Lie, Jesper Christensen, Oyvind Hesjedal Loven, Lars Varinger
Relatively objective and fair assessment of the career of journalist Seymour Hersh, who played a critical role in uncovering many of the most sensational stories of the past fifty years, from the My Lai Massacre to Watergate and Iraq, and, lately, Gaza. Hersh is a bit of a pip: self-educated, mostly, roguish, incredibly self-confident, but he is mostly right about major issues and righteously outraged by government and corporate malfeasance. He is charming and honest and the documentary avoids the common pitfalls of worship and selectivity. He acknowledges that his book JFK's affairs may have been a misstep. Other journalists take turns relating their own experiences with Hersh; they are mostly flattering, but sometimes not. Invaluable as a survey of the biggest news stories of the past fifty years-- as news stories. As objects of journalistic enterprise. Genuinely interesting.
Seymour Hersh, Bob Woodward, David Obst, Max Friedman, Jeff Gerth, Carl Bernstein
Exquisite, searing drama (in a quiet way) about a family reunion on the occasion of the anniversary of the death of the eldest son, Junpei, who drowned while rescuing a boy, Yoshio, at the beach. We see the event through the eyes of each of the main characters in turn, Ryota (Ryo), the younger son, who is treated with contempt by his father (a doctor) for not being worthy of succeeding Junpei as "heir", the mother, who is acerbic and harbors a dark secret about her husband-- who is bitter and cynical and contemptuous--, his sister and her husband, who quietly mock the family culture, (and anticipate moving back into the family home to look after the aging parents), and, most touchingly, Ryota's wife, Yukari, who maintains a delicate decorum throughout the meals and conversations that take place. One of the reasons Ryota's father (and mother, to some extent) are contemptuous or Ryota is that he has married a widow with a young son, Yatsuchi, who observes the family interactions with interest and curiosity. The tensions in the family are revealed slowly, through the meals, the taking of a group photo (father leaves abruptly), the baths, the gift of a kimono to Yukari, and the disruptive visit by Yoshio, who is invited every year not because Ryota's mother likes him but precisely because she hates him and admits that she gets satisfaction at watching him suffer through these awkward gatherings. Ryota's father regards him as unworthy of having been saved. Beautifully written, filmed, and edited by Koreeda who has stated that the family is inspired by his own family. The music was delicate and light and perhaps a bit too nimble for the subject.
Hiroshi Abe, Yui Natsukawa, You, Kazuya Takahashi, Shohei Tanaka, Hotaru Nomoto, Ryoga Hayashi, Susumu Terajima
All Contents Copyright © Bill Van Dyk 2017 All Rights Reserved
This is from \dev\moviespdo\reports\reports2024.php.