Category: Dra

Time: 89

Seen in Theatre? No

Date: 2025-10-03

Movie #: 3217 Title: Good One 2024

Rating: 6.30

Director (last): Donaldson (first): India


Writer (last): Donaldson (first): India


Chris and his daughter Sam and Chris' friend Matt set out on a hike along a wilderness trail in New York State. Matt's son, Dylan, decides to not accompany them at the last minute. Matt is kind of a dork-- he even forgets his sleeping bag in the car-- and Chris is not much better. The film reeks of a hatchet job on men in general. Sam cooks and cleans the dishes and imparts loads of precious wisdom to the two men, because, you know-- she's a girl. The men don't seem to have any means of navigation-- they just follow a trail without complication. Chris asks Sam if she is excited about "college", as if there was no particular college she was going to-- just, you know, a college. Then one night, while Chris is asleep, Matt proposes that Sam come into his tent to warm him up. I am not capable to giving this the weight director Donaldson clearly wishes it to have. Sam is devastated and hurt, and even more devastated and hurt when her father is dismissive of the impropriety. She takes revenge but loading his backpack with rocks while he is doing something somewhere. Then she sets out on her own to finish the trail, without explanation. Her father then asks her to drive, which some accept as a token of recognition of something. That he is an asshole, like all men? Do I take any meaning from the fact that they drive a Subaru? One cannot imagine that the writers or director ever went on an overnight hike near any kind of wilderness. Nor can one imagine that anyone involved has any clue about father-daughter relationships. I'm not saying there aren't dim-witted dads out there capable of being ignorant about their daughter's feelings: but no relationship of that duration could be so bereft of intuition or complexity or history or culture. The relationship has no personality, so when we are asked to recognize something tragic about his indifference to her angst about Matt's improper gesture, we whiff. Final note here: Sheila O'Malley at RogerEbert.com inexplicably raved about the film and gave it 4 our 4 stars. She should be impeached for malpractice. No matter how sympathetic you are to the muted politics of this film, no responsible critic should be giving this film the same rating as "The Godfather" or dozens of other acclaimed filmed. That is insane.


Is this movie a "gem"? No

Evil Twin: Little Miss Sunshine

Good Twin: Leave No Trace,

 

Added: 2025-10-03 [yyyy-mm-dd]